3 ms·
That's an interesting question. Is the VID a signal of protocol compatibility? Or a brand name? In a way it's both, but since end users almost never see the VI
by wpietri 12y ago
That's an interesting question. Is the VID a signal of protocol compatibility? Or a brand name?
In a way it's both, but since end users almost never see the VID, I suspect a lawyer would have an easy time that under the law it's more the former than the latter, and therefore not covered under trademark and related laws.
- welterde 12y agoEspecially since it's the only way to be compatible as far as I know (since (VID,PID) determines the driver that will get loaded for proprietary protocols). Also.. Can you even claim any special rights to a non-government registered trademark/brand name (one that is registered at a non-government entity - the USB Implementers Forum in this case)?
- jessaustin 12y agoIt seems like trademark would be really difficult to attach to (VID, PID) if no one in the supply chain actually used any USB-IF logos. Basically FTDI assumed a right to destroy property based on a violation of a contract neither the property owner, nor any of the chain of vendors that produced the property, had been a party to.