2 ms·
Just playing devil's advocate: Do you have any evidence specifically that their driver destroyed your chip, or could there be reasonable doubt that your counte
by Alupis 12y ago
Just playing devil's advocate:
Do you have any evidence specifically that their driver destroyed your chip, or could there be reasonable doubt that your counterfeit chip died? For a class-action suit that a lot of people seem to be talking about, you would have to have evidence that this was what did your chip in. And getting enough people (who appear to be mostly end-users) to submit the necessary evidence could be quite the task (most probably will just assume the device croaked one day and toss it out).
- serf 12y agoIt's very easy to spot, as the driver 'bricks' the chip by resetting it's PID.
- Alupis 12y agowell, the PID is not a physical thing. So for the average user, "the board just died on my one day". Getting wide-spread testing and evidence submitting would be challenging I think.
- wpietri 12y agoI don't see why that would be more challenging than any other class-action suit. Indeed, this looks easier, in that you have widespread media coverage and plenty of experts speaking out publicly. It's not a question of trying to find experts qualified to testify; here, you can pick from a bunch. The technology here is also much more straightforward than, say, an automobile, and there are successful class-action suits involving those all the time.
- Alupis 12y agothere isn't really any media coverage, other than the forum posts and HN. Also, using your automobile example, an average-joe consumer can take their car into a mechanic and have it tested for a recall/defect. The average-joe with an arduino is far more likely to toss the defective unit out, rather than try to spend a while troubleshooting a $40 board. I just don't see a class-action really able to take off. Especially since we're talking about otherwise illegal counterfeit chips in the first place.
- wpietri 12y agoOk. This looks like media coverage to me: http://www.zdnet.com/ftdi-admits-to-bricking-innocent-users-chips-in-silent-update-7000035019/ http://www.zdnet.com/ftdi-admits-to-bricking-innocent-users-... The line of argument "I, as some random anonymous person on the internet, can't see X" doesn't do much for me. Lots of people can't see lots of things, but most of the time that turns out to be about failures of knowledge or imagination, not evidence that that what they're talking about is impossible. Further, I don't think it's really my job to make people see things. (Well, actually, it is, but I charge by the day for that.) If you don't see it, I can live with that.
- Alupis 12y agoNot entirely sure what your argument was here, you sort of drifted into the weeds a bit. I think you meant to argue: "There is one source of media coverage, although it's largely just twitter comments. And just because something is difficult to prove doesn't mean it's not provable." Both are valid arguments. I don't count ZDnet as a very credible source of news, and in this case, some googling seems to show they are practically the only "news site" running this story. Although, as pointed out, it's mostly just a paragraph followed by several twitter posts. Secondly, the evidence thing is important if a case like this were to proceed. In order to sign onto the class action, you would have to prove you purchased an effected chip/board, and that this driver is what killed your product. Two problems here: 1) You bought a counterfeit chip/board. It's unlikely any award will be levied for illegal/infringing products. 2) Users would have to show evidence they were effected. Even in the RedBull class action case that is settling now, you must prove you bought a RedBull during the time period the case covers (receipt or whatever). Again, you have a counterfeit product, which was illegal to sell/buy in the first place. Not to mention, getting average-joe to test his device, even if someone made a testing utility and freely distributed it, will be close to impossible. People who are technical and care may do it, but average-joe will assume his arduino went belly-up one day, and likely toss it in the garbage. Let's be realistic. A handful of people in-the-know will care passionately, and do everything they can to further a claim. Several handfuls of people will care enough to do something if they believe they will get something in return (a payout). The rest will have no clue this is even a thing, and will simply throw away their "defective" device. What FTI did was wrong. But there is no real recourse here.
- nknighthb 12y ago> reasonable doubt Even if such existed (it does not), this standard is not applicable to a civil case, only to the criminal trials for destruction of property/malicious mischief that every single person involved should have to go through.
- Alupis 12y agoFor counterfeit/illegal property? This seems reminiscent of the guy who bought cocaine from his dealer, found out it was cut with flour, then tried to file a police report. I'd think you've had a tough time convincing a judge that you genuinely believed the chip/board you bought from some shady seller on eBay based in China for pennies on the dollar was a legit product. None-the-less, someone will try I'm sure. Then everyone can enjoy the $5 check they get in the mail 1 year later.
- nknighthb 12y agoThis has been thoroughly covered in an earlier thread[0]. The chips do not in themselves violate any law. To whatever extent there may be a trademark violation, that is between FTDI and whoever mislabeled them. None of this entitles FTDI to destroy anyone's property. That's a crime. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8493849 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8493849