4 ms·
The Myth of Crowdsourcing
- RyanMcGreal 17y agoBit of a straw man. "Crowdsourcing" per se is the idea of capturing and combining the individual contributions of many different people to produce an aggregate result that is far greater than any individual contribution. More specifically, it entails the idea that the barrier to contribution is very low, i.e. if someone only wants to make a very modest contribution - say, changing a misspelled possessive "it's" to "its" in a Wikipedi article - their small contribution can still be captured. In contrast, a more corporate collaboration model requires that every employee puts in a roughly equivalent level of contribution, which raises the barrier to entry too high for people who only want to make one small change. Wikipedia would be much smaller without the dedication of page curators; but it would also be much smaller (and more error-ridden) without the myriad small contributions of low-scale, occasional editors.
- skolor 17y agoI know its a little off topic, but every time I hear it mentioned I want to say something about it: Rather than complain about the typos or inaccuracies on Wikipedia, fix them. I've had an account registered for a couple of years, and might put in a handful of small edits every few months. It adds up, and just complain about it like people tend to do doesn't help anything.
- RyanMcGreal 17y agoOne of the nice things about the Wikipedia model is that you can materially improve an article on a given topic without actually knowing anything about that topic. I'm no wikipedian high roller, but I've taken a moment or two to clean up the spelling and grammar on several articles over the years.
- timwiseman 17y agoYou have a good point. But the main articles point is that much of what is called crowdsourcing isn't. It is the work of one individual out of a crowd to which a few others may or may not make smaller contributions. This is not to say that there are not true crowdsourced projects (despite what the article says, I think wikipedia is a shining example) but that many things identified as crowdsourced are not, or at least not in the way that the nontechnical public thinks of it.
- yarapavan 17y agoFrom the article: "So what's my problem? Why does it bug me that people think crowdsourcing is something it is not? Why do I care that people think a crowd is capable of individual virtuosity? What bugs me is that misplaced faith in the crowd is a blow to the image of the heroic inventor. We need to nurture and fund inventors and give them time to explore, play and fail. A false idea of the crowd reduces the motivation for this investment, with the supposition that companies can tap the minds of inventors on the cheap."
- wglb 17y agoThis article gets several things wrong. First, it repeats the error that the netflix prize was a crowdsourced accomplishment. In the sense of "The Wisdom of Crowds" it was not. Crowdsourcing in that sense is the result of combining opinions or outputs from individuals acting independently. The combined teams in the finals of the netflix competition were not operating independently. Additionally, Aaron Swartz in http://www.aaronsw.com/weblog/whowriteswikipedia http://www.aaronsw.com/weblog/whowriteswikipedia does actual research to show who writes wikipedia, and it counters what Jimmy Wales says about who writes wikipedia. But the author has a much better haircut than I and is unmistakably more handsome.
- ivankirigin 17y agoI think how Facebook translated the site is one of the biggest examples of proper crowdsourcing. It does take some expertise - namely knowledge of two languages. But the set of people with that kind of knowledge is definitely big enough to call it a crowd. I'll have to ask internally at Facebook how many people were involved. My guess would be more than 1000.
- gruseom 17y agoSloppy thinking. A given Wikipedia article may be the work of an individual, but Wikipedia is the work of many. Really, his only point is that he doesn't like the word "crowdsourcing" because he doesn't like crowds. If it were called "herosourcing" instead, he'd have written the same article about how great Wikipedia etc. are.