3 ms·
I tend to think Gamergate was a brewing culture war that was just looking for a spark to start the fire. Gamer culture has had a persecution complex for well o
by Pxtl 12y ago
I tend to think Gamergate was a brewing culture war that was just looking for a spark to start the fire. Gamer culture has had a persecution complex for well over a generation, particularly with respect to the press - even the gaming press. Being repeatedly insulted and attacked by the media has made them circle their wagons instinctively. Combined with a substantial fraction of gamers that are intensely misogynistic and this ugliness was practically inevitable.
The problem is that gamers picked a fight with SJWs, which are effectively their own mirror image - the same obsessiveness and mean-spirited put-downs and in-group high-fives. I mean, the fact that the SJWs are right is almost immaterial - in the words of The Big Lebowski: "You're not wrong, Walter, you're just an asshole". Online social justice groups have a knack for utterly alienating and insulting everyone they could ever hope to convince, even those who broadly agree with them.
Combine that with Gawker media's spectacular ability to stir the pot, and a few prominent right-wing culture-war bloggers feeding the gamer-gaters' persecution complex, and we're seeing outright radicalization.
You isolate and insult a guy and then give him an online culture of like-minded outcasts and they start encouraging each other to do drastic things. There are obvious parallels to other movements of angry young men...
It's a perfect storm, and it's only going to get worse before it gets better since anybody who's trying to talk the gamergaters down from the ledge has to have infinite patience for their monomaniacal rationalizations. They see themselves as the defenders of rationality surrounded by SJWs who fling glib insults... and gaming is founded on endlessly grinding against a pointless task for fun.
It's profoundly sad to see so many gamers rally behind that gamergate banner. To see harassment and threats and ruining women's lives become the public image of core gamer culture.
I'm really worried that this is going to get worse before it gets better. The "us vs. them" mentality of the hardcore gamer world is too old and well-established, and everybody else involved is either feeding into it or is drowned out by the din.
- ncallaway 12y agoI started seeing the phrase "Social Justice Warrior" used a lot as soon as #Gamergate happened. I have yet to see it well defined, though. I realize it's tangential to your point, but I'm curious how would you define or describe a SJW?
- meowface 12y agoTraditionally, the term has been used to describe people who make comments like http://i.imgur.com/QMbGVLG.png http://i.imgur.com/QMbGVLG.png or http://i.imgur.com/vJgiov8.jpg http://i.imgur.com/vJgiov8.jpg or http://i.imgur.com/fMcjKsg.png http://i.imgur.com/fMcjKsg.png. Essentially, radical social justice viewpoints taken to absurd extremes. Sometimes to the point of expressing highly racist, homophobic, or transphobic views in the course of supporting some other group they feel is even more persecuted than those groups. Now, the term is being thrown around by some people to describe those who are left leaning and support a viewpoint they disagree with. So-called "Social Justice Warriors" are indeed an actual and rather ridiculous (yet amusing) group on the Internet, mostly centered around Tumblr, but their overall population density is pretty low compared to progressives and feminists in general.
- ANTSANTS 12y agoMore examples of the first group, because we could all use a laugh: http://a.pomf.se/vrwobd.png http://a.pomf.se/vrwobd.png http://a.pomf.se/mdiqol.jpg http://a.pomf.se/mdiqol.jpg http://a.pomf.se/jdwkkw.png http://a.pomf.se/jdwkkw.png http://a.pomf.se/brsunc.png http://a.pomf.se/brsunc.png http://a.pomf.se/wcjfcv.jpg http://a.pomf.se/wcjfcv.jpg Some examples of the second group might include the people who flagkilled half of my comments in this thread. Man, I know political threads on Reddit News are a steaming pile, but y'all could at least pretend to be capable of talking to people you don't agree with and downvote me into oblivion instead.
- DanBC 12y agoIt's weird to see the term "sjw" used by someone who isn't a repellant fuckwit. It's been a reliable flag -at least on HN- so far. That's something you might want to be aware of.
- Pxtl 12y agoI'd gotten the impression they and their supporters had started to self-identify with the term.
- chillingeffect 12y agoI believe the speed of communication, gratis internet, has exceeded the speed at which a population can agree on the meaning of terms.
- meowface 12y agoAbsolutely. You can find this for even some of the most basic terms nowadays, like "feminist" and "liberal". Some people have extremely different ideas of what those 2 words mean. For example, I consider myself both liberal and a feminist, but I take serious umbrage with many of the "radical feminists" and very far left leaning voices that have emerged out of these debates. Those same people would simply be considered just plain old feminists or liberals by some others, though.
- chiaro 12y agoVery well put. The phrase "perfect storm" crossed my mind when I first heard of this.