3 ms·
Is there a good anti-iPhone rant somewhere that avoids logical fallacies and would help me understand why some people are averse to iPhone development? I don't
by natch 17y ago
Is there a good anti-iPhone rant somewhere that avoids logical fallacies and would help me understand why some people are averse to iPhone development? I don't get it.
Central point of control == bad?
I don't buy it. JWZ is a central point of control for DNA Lounge, I assume; PG is a close to a central point of control for YC news; Linus is a central point of control for Linux kernel enhancements -- or was, for a while; I haven't been keeping up so if I'm wrong, please understand the general point, which is: we happily accept central control as long as there is good will.
DRM == bad?
Again, though I agree, Apple's implementation of DRM for Apps has gotten it far closer to right than any other, with family sharing of one purchase on multiple devices, refunds, DRM-free music, free updates, remembering your purchase so you can re-download purchased items for free (remember the phone companies' model, buy a game, run out of memory, delete it, then if you want it later you have to buy it again?). Definitely iPhone is not free, in the freedom sense, and downright scary, in the your-app-can-be-yanked-at-any-time sense, but I believe the same is true on Android; we just haven't seen the test case yet.
iPhone is not open == bad
OK... but it's a platform. Lots of platforms are open only down to certain layers. Google is a platform. But it only exposes certain parts of itself for developers to use. And we understand that. So why do we not understand it when it comes to a phone? Maybe because it's such a personal device?
It doesn't let us do everything == bad
I think this comes closest to being an answer. This would be the answer for me. But, neither does any other device. I continue to think that Android developers are naive to assume they are not going to bump up against limits imposed by carriers and by Google. They just don't have the critical mass to have hit all the nooks and crannies yet.
Apple is not friendly to open source == bad.
Grand Central Dispatch, LLVM, Clang (probably there are more) all would indicate otherwise.
So, what am I missing? Not trying to troll here. I'm sure I have exhibited some ignorance in this long post, seriously. Why are (some small number of smart) people pounding their heads against the wall rather than develop for iPhone?
- dschobel 17y agoIt's not the centralized control but rather how Apple is applying it to further their business agenda at the expense of their users' access to an awesome Google technology.
- protomyth 17y agoSince Google blocks some rural numbers, and I do believe I am in a region where they block, I am thinking it is not very awesome at all.
- scythe 17y ago>I don't buy it. JWZ is a central point of control for DNA Lounge, I assume; PG is a close to a central point of control for YC news; Linus is a central point of control for Linux kernel enhancements -- or was, for a while; I haven't been keeping up so if I'm wrong, please understand the general point, which is: we happily accept central control as long as there is good will. I think what you're looking for is right here: >as long as there is good will. I don't think nearly as many people would be angry over the App Store if the approval process were sane. Also... >OK... but it's a platform. Sure, but before the iPhone, application development for phones was, in general, significantly more open. If I wanted to deploy a Symbian OS application three years ago, I wrote it and let people download it. Windows Mobile was similar. It's not the fact that it's not open, but it's the fact that it moves the industry towards less openness that's concerning.
- mhansen 17y agoBased on what I've read: Apple's decision-making process on what gets into the App Store is completely opaque, and has a hugely variable turn-around rate. Developers need to push updates out quickly, and Apple's approval process is actively hampering such efforts. There have been many posts detailing horrible cases of delays in approval, where the developer has been unable to have anyone to contact at Apple. Also, there has been no word from Apple as to what they are doing, if anything, to fix the long and inconsistent approval process
- plinkplonk 17y ago"So, what am I missing? Why are (some small number of smart) people pounding their heads against the wall rather than develop for iPhone?" Annual development fees == bad ! I hope that helped you understand why a few of us have reservations about developing for the IPhone. I developed Win32 apps once, including for WinME phones. I didn't have to pay annual fees to Microsoft. I (for one) will never develop for the IPhone as long as they charge annual development fees - basically I have to rent the right to develop from Apple annually. No Thanks!
- jrockway 17y agoI don't buy it. JWZ is a central point of control for DNA Lounge, I assume; PG is a close to a central point of control for YC news; Linus is a central point of control for Linux kernel enhancements But the point is, JWZ is not a central point of control for all nightclubs, PG is not a central point of control for my startup, and Linus is not the central point of control for every Free operating system. Apple controls devices that you own whether or not you want Apple to have that control. If I want to pay a friend to write an application for me, I have to get Apple's permission. This is a different kind of control than "if I want pg to give me free money, I have to convince pg to do so". Apple is injecting itself between parties that do not want Apple in the middle. (The word "wiretapping" comes to mind.)