2 ms·
"ZFC is consistent with …" must, of course, be replaced by "If ZFC is consistent, then so are …". In fact, singling out ZFC gives you another example of this k
by JadeNB 12y ago
"ZFC is consistent with …" must, of course, be replaced by "If ZFC is consistent, then so are …".
In fact, singling out ZFC gives you another example of this kind of result: if ZF is consistent, then so are ZF+C and ZF-C.
- thaumasiotes 12y agoThat all depends whether you're comfortable saying a contradiction is "consistent" with an unrelated proposition; I don't see much of a problem with it. Contradictions, being impossible, are logically consistent with everything else. I guess unprovable propositions would switch over to being provable, though.
- JadeNB 12y ago> That all depends whether you're comfortable saying a contradiction is "consistent" with an unrelated proposition; I don't see much of a problem with it. Contradictions, being impossible, are logically consistent with everything else. I guess unprovable propositions would switch over to being provable, though. Oh, I see. I read "A is consistent with B" as "A+B is consistent", but I can see the validity of the reading "A+B is 'as consistent as' A".