3 ms·
> Cities are very dense and, in the scheme of human existence, unnatural places. I think that this kind of statement must be qualified very carefully. I belie
by JadeNB 12y ago
> Cities are very dense and, in the scheme of human existence, unnatural places.
I think that this kind of statement must be qualified very carefully. I believe (though I don't know) that cities are unnatural in the sense that they don't arise in nature among other animals than humans; but I'd be reluctant to call them unnatural for humans, in the sense that it seems to me that a large part of what makes us human is the ability to live together and function (well or poorly!) in large groups.
- bokonist 12y agoFor most of the duration of the evolution of the human race, humans were living in groups of < 50 people. Cities of tens of thousands of people are a very recent phenomena. That said, evolution did not halt 5,000 years ago, and there probably are even more recent genetic selective pressure that has made it easier for people to live together in cities. But still, my broader point stands, a lot of rules and conditioning are needed for people to live together without driving each other crazy. Some of this conditioning we are not even conscious of, because the conditioning occurred when we are so young. But when you watch the parents of young children, you see how much effort it takes to do well.
- Someone 12y ago"I believe (though I don't know) that cities are unnatural in the sense that they don't arise in nature among other animals than humans" Depends on what you consider a city. Ants, bees, termites, naked mole rats all live in densely populated 'buildings', with specialized division of labor between their inhabitants. Also, bat, bird or seal colonies can get incredibly dense.
- JadeNB 12y ago> Depends on what you consider a city. Ants, bees, termites, naked mole rats all live in densely populated 'buildings', with specialized division of labor between their inhabitants. Also, bat, bird or seal colonies can get incredibly dense. I think that there is no better way to learn interesting facts than to make confident assertions on the Internet. :-)
- innguest 12y agoProselytizing causes learning because it creates doubt in others (that will then build arguments to refute the assertions) and in the self (through doxastic aporia). But the current mainstream thinking of relativism, where values are inverted, also thinks learning is bad (which is why we don't do it in schools and universities anymore), and so earnest discussions are discouraged and deemed offensive (but 5 minute shout matches on the news are still fair game).
- JadeNB 12y agoUmm … I feel like I'm being scolded for something, but I'm not sure what—or maybe I am just mis-reading. :-)
- innguest 12y agoI was agreeing with you and saying I also do that (make confident assertions to spur a conversation while being fully open to the possibility I'm wrong, because it seems to be a more efficient route than everyone doing infinite research before saying anything). Sorry if that seemed rude or anything. EDIT: example of this at work: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8514048 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8514048