5 ms·
Running the Roman Catholic Church perhaps? Providing spiritual leadership to a billion Catholics worldwide?
by philwelch 12y ago
Running the Roman Catholic Church perhaps? Providing spiritual leadership to a billion Catholics worldwide?
- JoeAltmaier 12y ago...and these religious documents they've curated, why did they do that? Presumably because they illuminate spiritual matters. Their dissemination directly relates to that goal. Or, they stole them because they were worth coin, and they are greedy. Which conclusion would you prefer I make? Never mind, either way they should pay the freight on this task.
- philwelch 12y agoNo one's saying you have to give one red cent. If enough other people find value in contributing to the project that's up to them. So why you mad, bro? For an institution that's millennia old and used to be the most powerful institution in the Western world, I'd be surprised if they didn't have a massive trove of historical manuscripts just out of historical accident.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoLets imagine Merke wanted to crowd-fund their next drug? Or your banker crowd-funding interest? Or the local Laundromat crowd-funding soap? I just find it very strange.
- danielweber 12y agoBecause those operations will fund it by selling the end product. Either the Church funds it by voluntary donations (from parishioners), or they fund it by voluntary donations (from people who want the documents put out for free).
- philwelch 12y agoWell those are for-profit business enterprises. The Vatican is the head of the Catholic Church, and as everyone else is pointing out, it's already crowdfunded.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- orionblastar 12y agoNot so strange because these books are not being sold, and there is no commercial aspect to it. Just the pursuit of knowledge and even books that have beliefs that are contrary to theirs but they are making them public and free to access. Even books written about Jesus that didn't make it into the Bible and were considered heresy. All of the books are being digitized for educational purposes and free to access to the public. Will Merke give out free drugs, will the banker forgive loans and give out interest free loans, will the laundromat give out free soap? Nope, because they are commercial and in it for the profits and money. This move by the Vatican is not about profits, but more about freeing the information in these books for the public to benefit from for free.
- crpatino 12y agoHonestly man, leave your religious hate at the doorstep. It's like saying that, because Motorola was making lot's money on the electronics business back in the day, then ought to provide Six Sigma Black Belt Certifications for free.
- Karunamon 12y agoIt isn't religious hate. The Vatican is a stupidly well-off organization, and seeing well off organizations panhandling for things they can easily fund themselves seems disingenuous, at the least.
- lil_cain 12y agoCitation needed for the vatican being a stupidly well off organisation. Preferably in terms of its annual budget (rather than capital assets, which would be a silly way to pay for this). And even well off institutions have priorities. I suspect "digitising historical manuscripts" is pretty low on the priority list of the Holy See. Given that the Holy See would prefer to fund other things, this is a pretty reasonable idea. If people fund it, then they'll do it. If people aren't interested enough to fund it, then they won't.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoStop right there. I'm a Catholic. That doesn't mean I give the Vatican a free pass when it makes a boneheaded announcement like this. Keep your ad-hominem attacks to yourself.
- crpatino 12y agoI am a Catholic too, though marginally attached to the Church due to multiple and systematic dubious ethical decisions from the top of our clergy hierarchy (of which the de-facto protection of pederast priests is just the tip of the iceberg). That does not mean I will go around finding reasons to criticize everything they do. They have (presumed) legitimate possession of an invaluable wealth of historic documents. It is therefore their prerogative to decide to whom they give access to it. It is a good thing they decided to digitize those documents and put them on the web. It is also a good thing they will have open access for free. What the heck are you freaking out about? According to your logic, this is a "boneheaded announcement" because of what? Because they are looking for means to finance the operation without forking out their own money? Everybody does it, governments, corporations, non profits, individuals! But somehow, Vatican is special! If it does not live up to the highest (irrational) ideals, they it must be rotten to the core! St Ambrose said "The Church is both saint and whore"[1]. And somehow you seem disappointed that the saint-whore does too much sainting and too little whoring. [1] Wrongfully attributed to St Augustine of Hippo.
- huxley 12y agoIf it was for a drug that might not otherwise be made or sold at usurious prices, I wouldn't be against crowdfunding it, so long as it was available under reasonable terms like the Vatican Library documents are. Laundromats I've gone to expect you to bring your own soap. And I'm not sure what the banker example is about but will admit it sounds bad.