3 ms·
The WMDs that ISIS has found in Iraq and is using now?
by gadders 12y ago
The WMDs that ISIS has found in Iraq and is using now?
- ta74747 12y agoThe pretext for the war was Iraq having an active WMD program. What ISIS has are stockpiles from before Iraq dismantled their WMD program (which was prior to the invasion).
- runjake 12y agoWMD stockpiles supplied by the US for use against the Iranians in the 1980s. So in fact, we had a pretty good idea that Saddam had WMDs. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iraq_and_weapons_of_mass_destruction#Western_help_with_Iraq.27s_WMD_program http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iraq_and_weapons_of_mass_destru...
- csorrell 12y agoI was under the impression that the shelf life on most of these WMDs (chemical nerve agents) is only 5 years or so. So we had a pretty good idea about what Saddam was holding, but they were almost certainly unusable at the time of the invasion.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- gadders 12y agoThe active WMD program that Clinton believed in as well? So don't need to worry about these WMDs then if they're not part of an active program?
- rhino369 12y agoIraq was sort of bluffing about having chemical weapons after the Gulf War and before the second invasion. It wasn't crazy to think they had an active program. The Bush administration didn't think they could just make up WMD. They assumed the WMD was there. Their real failure was that they pressured the intelligence community into giving a fast confirmation that WMD existed. It's sort of like when a cop lies on the stand by bolstering his evidence. The cop usually isn't trying to rail road an innocent person but insuring (in his mind) the conviction of a guilty person. That is what Bush's administration thought. Turns out the program was finished after the Gulf War and never restarted. And a real hard intelligence look should have shown that. But dissenters were quieted. The "WMD" that was found was lost, pre Gulf War munitions that were degraded to uselessness. They were for most purposes, useless. It was shitty, old as fuck mustard gas. So yes, really no need to worry.
- gadders 12y agoWeird. Everyone seems worried about them now. So Bush managed to pressure Clinton into believing into Iraqi WMDs even before he was elected? That's a neat trick.
- washadjeffmad 12y agoIt's more of a semantics issue from bad intel and some FUDdy massaging of the definitions along the way, but I see how you got there. Iraq had chemical weapons, and, if you've seen the news, we found them in 2006, although it wasn't publicly confirmed until recently. The use of the label "WMD" is the matter in contention. Some chemical weapons can be WMDs, but these weren't. They also weren't active, and they weren't the type or scale that could be used in modern warfare. The situation was closer to cleaning out an old chemical factory than a race against time to find and disarm fleets of intercontinental missiles primed for launch from secret subterranean silos across the country.
- maxerickson 12y agoThis article characterizes them as not being militarily useful: http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/jul/09/isis-seizes-chemical-weapons-plant-muthanna-iraq http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/jul/09/isis-seizes-che... It's leaning on statements from the U.S. State department, but I guess the WSJ isn't just a trumpet for State: http://online.wsj.com/articles/sunni-extremists-in-iraq-occupy-saddams-chemical-weapons-facility-1403190600 http://online.wsj.com/articles/sunni-extremists-in-iraq-occu... Are there credible reports that they are being used?
- gwern 12y agoYour conservative talking point is deeply misinformed, but since I've already criticized it elsewhere, I'll just link that: http://lesswrong.com/lw/l49/what_false_beliefs_have_you_held_and_why_were_you/bgyk http://lesswrong.com/lw/l49/what_false_beliefs_have_you_held...
- gadders 12y agoThank you for linking to your own opinion on a different website. Your liberal viewpoint is deeply misinformed. The fear of WMDs was also shared by Bill Clinton when still in power, Hosni Mubarak, the French Intelligence services, Nancy Pelosi and Harry Reid. The WMDs found may not be on a scale with what, say, Russia could produce or even on a scale with what was expected, but they were there.
- gwern 12y ago> The fear of WMDs was also shared by Bill Clinton when still in power, Hosni Mubarak, the French Intelligence services, Nancy Pelosi and Harry Reid. Based on misinformation, paranoia, and earlier perspectives. > The WMDs found The 'WMDs' were only found when you equivocate on the term 'WMDs' to equate the terrifying prospects specifically laid out by Bush & Cheney, the details of which I quoted in my link (nukes, mobile bio-labs, etc), with the tiny supply of chemical weapons already known about and dealt with by the UN. By your logic, white is black, and 0 is 1. After all, they're very similar, it's just a matter of scale... > or even on a scale with what was expected. Bingo. You even understand the point. It's like claiming to be a millionaire when one is actually unemployed and has just a few dollars left in one's bank account. 'Yes, maybe my wealth was not on a scale with what you expected, but it was there!' They're only equivalent if you're blind.
- gadders 12y agoSo here's the thing - even if the chemical weapons found were not as massive as you expected, there is still enough evidence there to believe that the invasion was undertaken in good faith.