6 ms·
This is a great argument for a high minimum wage.
by mrfusion 12y ago
This is a great argument for a high minimum wage.
- innguest 12y agoMinimum wage is a ban on jobs. It means the government passes a law forbidding people from selling their labor for less than $X. Before you defend minimum wage, you should try and come up with a coherent explanation as to how is it that any good can come from curtailing people's freedoms by prohibiting them from setting their own prices for the labor they wish to sell.
- Symmetry 12y agoWhat, to encourage automation instead of using humans? If it really is cheaper to use humans there's no reason to prevent that, there are plenty of places we need automation that will cause technology to keep advancing. Better to let the market chose humans or automation as it wills (and then buff up the social safety net if this throws too many people out of work).
- ethbro 12y agoHow is this an argument for a high minimum wage, as opposed to a basic human (non-employment-linked) wage?
- mrfusion 12y agoI think either would solve the problem the article describes. I actually prefer your solution.
- innguest 12y agoWhat would be the good or service sold in order to generate the wealth to be distributed to all humans as basic wage? And who would be the generous folks doing all the work to produce those goods and services, while being OK with sharing, with everyone, the goods (i.e. money) that they trade their goods for? I'm just trying to understand your suggestion.
- zackmorris 12y agoIn a lot of ways, money is a measure of inefficiency. For example, if everyone had the education, experience and time to repair their own vehicles/homes etc, they wouldn't have to pay someone else to do it. We would see the costs of those services decrease, along with the income of people who would otherwise provide them. We're seeing this all over in the economy with Amazon, eBay, Craigslist, etc. As better rapid prototyping, artificial general intelligence, and moneyless transactions like BitCoin become mainstream, there will be less and less exchange of money. However, the overall wealth created in the economy will only increase. We're rapidly approaching a point in time (well before the singularity) where human labor can't compete with automation. We can stick with the current system of capitalism where all of the gains go to a few at the top and everyone else is in a race to the bottom to preserve their jobs. Or.. We can adopt a system that works to maximize the social good instead of production, profits, influence, things that we might think of as 20th century goals. My current favorite alternative is cooperativism, where the workers own the means of production so there is no need for unions. One example is WinCo, which simultaneously provides lower prices than Walmart and higher wages/benefits to its employees because it doesn’t spend exorbitant amounts on advertising or dividends (which tend to run 15-30% of a for-profit corporation’s overhead, sometimes more). Ironically one of the biggest problems with cooperativism is the lack of community ownership. So a company like Valve can be regarded as the epitome of cooperativism, where the workers can potentially make billions of dollars and the community makes nothing other than taxes. In many cases even those are waived, for example in Boise where I live, Micron and hp get enormous tax waivers to attract them. Some cities even pay corporations bonuses to move there. So the only solution that I see is to raise taxes on businesses and to abandon the idea of corporate profits so that high income individuals pay the tax rates that the US enjoyed in its highest growth decades. That would mean a readjustment of our tax brackets to match inflation since then. I would suggest few or no taxes at or below the median individual income of roughly $40,000 per year, and then use a logarithmic scale beyond that. If it was base 2, then to double one’s net income, they would need to make 4 times as much, so $160,000 per year instead of $80,000. They would pay a tax of $80,000 on that or 50%. To make 4 times median, they would have to make $640,000 per year, and pay $480,000 in taxes or 75%. If base 2 seems too high, then society would vote on which base is most fair, probably settling on something similar to what we use today below $250,000 and eliminating the loopholes above that. This is basically a flat tax in a nonlinear system. That way we get the wage/innovation benefits of a cooperative and the social benefit of a public income stream. As cooperatives become larger, they would have a choice to pay their workers in innovation (providing free food and benefits like Google) or pay society at large through taxes if they choose cash. In other words, society gets a win-win, because non-cash innovation is the stuff of Star Trek, and even cash is still cash. The US GDP is $16 trillion, so spread over the 160 million workers, that’s roughly $100,000 per person. The missing $60,000 reflects our wealth inequality, which means we could switch to this system today and give everyone a basic income of $40,000 and the rich would have $20,000 to spare. In other words, tax policy alone could provide for everyone right now (the way they do it in social democracies like Finland) but since the US seems averse to that, I expect cooperativism to be the path of least resistance, meaning that capitalism will eventually adopt it as the social ills of vast wealth inequality become unpalatable and we seek a peaceful reconciliation (as opposed to an uprising like the French Revolution). To answer your original question: the endgame here is that our union (the United States was originally a union after all) becomes a conglomerate of cooperatives, and eventually a cooperative itself. So a person could join a co-op and earn $40,000 above and beyond their state-provided basic income of $40,000. But since wealth inequality already takes a larger share of income than most people earn, I think we’ll find that people migrate toward a renaissance in leisure. After all, if wages had kept up with inflation, the minimum wage would be $22/hr today, and the median income would be twice as much, or about $80,000. That’s more than most people need to live on, so we’d see a lot of 4 day work weeks, 6 hour work days, 2 months off a year, and people investing half their income and retiring at 30 anyway (essentially a private basic income as opposed to a public one). That was supposed to be the American dream, but we’ve been swindled out of it by 30 years of trickle down economics. If this seems inflammatory, well, it is, and you’ll notice that you never hear about this on the mainstream media. Please check my figures. I stand by this premise and highly recommend learning about progressivism and the history of labor since the Gilded Age, and the various ways in which the country has backpedaled with things like the Gramm–Leach–Bliley Act, which lowered regulations on wall street and led to the Dot Bomb, the Housing Bubble and the Great Recession.