If you don't know why it sucks, how were you able to determine that it sucks? Figure out what you don't like about the site, then ask for ideas on how to fix i

If you don't know why it sucks, how were you able to determine that it sucks? Figure out what you don't like about the site, then ask for ideas on how to fix it, or hire someone to fix it. Your current method will get you lots of opinions, but they will be all over the map.