10 ms·
For some things, markets work pretty well. Prices go up, people have a big incentive to supply the good.
by davidw 12y ago
For some things, markets work pretty well. Prices go up, people have a big incentive to supply the good.
- vince_refiti 12y agoImagine if the Chinese were able to patent the process of mining and processing the rare metals. And bombarded everyone with frivolous lawsuits. Good thing these crazy scenarios don't happen.
- davidw 12y ago> patent the process of mining and processing the rare metals If they were to make big and non-obvious improvements that allow everyone to mine and/or process more efficiently, then that's exactly what patents are supposed to do: they get a temporary monopoly on those improvements in return for sharing them with the world. But I have the feeling you're just spouting off a bit :-)
- thescrewdriver 12y agoSince when did only non-obvious improvements get patented?
- briantakita 12y agoI suppose you don't agree with the phrase "standing on the shoulder of giants". The fact that, through history, people create novelty & discovery without the "incentive" of ownership, invalidates the "need" for patents to provide an "incentive" of exclusivity. Re: patents, those who own the capital also own the patents. It's simply a mechanism to control others by restricting who can use an idea originally developed by "standing on the shoulder of giants". So if you own lots of capital, patents allow you to control others. If you don't own lots of capital, patents are oppressive.
- davidw 12y ago> The fact that, through history, people create novelty & discovery without the "incentive" of ownership, invalidates the "need" for patents to provide an "incentive" of exclusivity. But are they creating at an optimal rate? Without patents, would they still create nearly as much stuff? It's a fascinating question. My view is that it's all a bit of a messy compromise, and neat, clean answers like "abolish patents" are probably a bad idea. I'd be in favor of some major reforms, and severely limit them in some fields.
- briantakita 12y agoWe made lots of progress without the systems of capitalism and patents. I dare say that the progress before the systems of capitalism & patents was more sustainable (environmentally & humanely). Much of the paradigm of economic scarcity is a false. Economic scarcity is a tool to enforce social order so those on top can control all of the resources. Capitalism needs scarcity for the profit motive. Farmers can't make as much profit if everybody has enough to eat and can receive food in a decentralized manner. We can have abundance. Hunger does not need to exist. We already produce enough food. We already produce enough ideas & innovation. Humans naturally create. No coercive incentive is needed. > clean answers like "abolish patents" are probably a bad idea It's probably a good idea to decentralize power & control. Power corrupts after all.
- stcredzero 12y agoImagine if the Chinese were able to patent the process... One of the big holes in our current system of patents is that they have inconsistent enforcement internationally. This is simultaneously a good and a bad thing.
- makomk 12y agoNot that well. The main reason they were the sole supplier in the first place was because they sold rare earths at prices low enough to drive all the other suppliers out of business; because of the amount of time it took mines and smelters to start running again, that gave them several years of monopoly. Repeat that a few times and other companies will learn not to even try competing.
- runeks 12y agoCan you point out to any practical examples where this has happened? The article in question demonstrates the market working well, I would say. Your hypothetical scenario goes against what we observed happen. I think it's reasonable to ask for an example or two in this case. Personally, I don't think your scenario will play out in real life. Competitors will appear when it is profitable for them to appear. Sure, there's a start-up cost (as with most forms of business), and this cost must be included when calculating profitability. But that doesn't change the fact that they will appear when it's profitable, it only increases the profit margin required for a profitable investment. Bottom line: a competitor will not appear until it can produce a commodity more cheaply than the market. And this is exactly what we want.