3 ms·
The most basic provision on a private sale of private stock places no restrictions on the sale that 'does not involve a public offering'. So in theory it's only
by zaroth 12y ago
The most basic provision on a private sale of private stock places no restrictions on the sale that 'does not involve a public offering'. So in theory it's only when you start "looking" for investors, when you are "publicly" selling the shares, then you want a Reg D 506 exemption, and accredited investors.
However, in practice the Section 4(a)(2) exemption is often not strong enough protection (since we're talking potentially significant civil and criminal charges) so companies go for the Reg D safe harbors even when not technically required. Particularly for unsophisticated / unaccredited investors, the courts have found that 4(a)(2) is not good enough, even when the sale was arguably private. See, for example, SEC v. Ralston Purina Co., 346 U.S. 119 (1953). [1]
Following the path of Reg D 506 is actually quite simple, and carries no downside. But even with Reg D 506 you generally try to avoid unsophisticated investors, since then you get into scenarios where you are supposed to provide 'access to the kind of information that a registration statement would disclose' which is very difficult. The crowdfunding regs in theory are supposed to help alleviate this.
[1] - http://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=6019539454143305122 http://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=6019539454143305...
[2] - IANAL
- zaroth 12y agoJust going to follow up on this to excerpt part of that Supreme Court decision; Exemption from the registration requirements of the Securities Act is the question. The design of the statute is to protect investors by promoting full disclosure of information thought necessary to informed investment decisions.[10] The natural way to interpret the private offering exemption is in light of the statutory purpose. Since exempt transactions are those as to which "there is no practical need for [the bill's] application," the applicability of § 4 (1) should turn on whether the particular class of persons affected needs the protection of the Act. An offering to those who are shown to be able to fend for themselves is a transaction "not involving any public offering." I truly dislike the logic, why can't we stick with the plain meaning of the text, but they are trying to protect people from swindlers so I can understand their goal. The end result is selling shares to the night janitor is almost certainly not allowed by 4(a)(2) but glad it turned out alright this time.