5 ms·
Fake versus Real FTDI USB Serial Chips
- ChuckMcM 12y agoA friend of mine just ran into this, and after investigation it seems it is quite the thing. Don't buy your chips on Ebay or Alibaba I guess.
- chrisBob 12y agoIts worse than that. Don't buy a board from Ebay or Alibaba.
- Someone1234 12y agoIts worse than that. Don't buy generic electrical goods w/USB from East Asia (they might be tainted by this, unbeknownst to you).
- zyxley 12y ago"Don't buy generic electrical goods from East Asia" is pretty good advice in general, given that some people have been literally electrocuted by faulty low-cost equipment sourced from the region.
- kuschku 12y ago“Only buy electronical goods from East Asia that passed VDE, TÜV Nord, GS and CE specifications and tests”. (Interestingly, a lot of the US–produced products do not pass these tests either. The German standards for product quality are some of the highest existing and they have actually the ability to test all the imported stuff. Just don’t ever trust the TÜV Süd)
- tmp26 12y agoThis might have just been rumor, but I've heard tell of devices with fake CE stickers.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoIt reminds me a bit of the great 'bad electrolytic capacitor' debacle that cost companies millions.
- pessimizer 12y agoExcept in this case, the quality of the fake is fine.
- rdl 12y agoSupply chain integrity is hard, especially when you're building things on a schedule, especially when you're building <50k in a batch, and when you're not super well known. I wish we'd bring back an electronics manufacturing industry to the US just for that reason alone, even at 2x the cost. Right now it seems the "safest" way to make boards in 5k units is in Mexico -- NAFTA rules plus cheaper labor and compliance.
- tmp26 12y agoSupposedly select parts are coming back, as big companies lose faith. (But not all of it will come back)
- Taniwha 12y agothe thing is that building a work alike chip - one that speaks the same protocols, has the same pinout, (but a different USBID/part number)is perfectly OK - price competition is good right? The vendors would have to write their own drivers but compared with the cost of spinning a chip that shouldn't be a big deal, if they'd come out and sold their chips on the open market as a clone they'd probably get a lot of business. Of course one of the weird things about ft232s is that they're non-standard USB devices (don't meet the ACM spec). If the cloners made ACM compatible chips they wouldn't need to write drivers since all OSs have them built in these days. Disclaimer: I build and sell open source USB boards, including serial devices (ACM, not ft232 compatible)
- tmp26 12y agoPrice competition is great! The shady thing about the imitations is trying to insert themselves into someone else's supply & support chain, IMO. Which is probably tied to the reason they didn't implement the ACM spec- from my limited hobbyist view, FTDI is the dominant player, so of course they would chose to mimic the non-standard ft232 instead of some underdog ACM player. Oh, and as for costs, you're totally right that spinning a chip costs way more than a driver. But: - A theme as I learn about fly-by-night companies is they piggyback on other operations. As the article observes, this knockoff required only 1 mask layer, because the rest is probably a standard microcontroller. - Marketing & marketshare are probably the real reason, not getting out of writing drivers. Again, FTDI seems to be the entrenched player.
- ash 12y agoWhat serial devices are ACM-compatible? How to check for it? Are there any modern OS that don't support ACM? Wikipedia article [1] is making it seem like ACM is only for modems, not for generic serial devices. Am I wrong? Thank you! [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USB_communications_device_class http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USB_communications_device_class
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- robomartin 12y agoPretty typical HN over-reaction. Why not wait to hear from FTDI before joining the lynching mob? If the driver broke clones without the express intention to cause damage, well, tough for the clones. If, on the other hand, they set out to actually cause damage they are out of business or will suffer greatly. There's another angle here. I'll use a hypothetical. Say your chips are being used on MRI machines, cars, planes, glucose meters, ATM machines and a whole host of other mission critical systems. And you know clones are dangerous because they are unreliable, failure prone and nondeterministic in some way. What do you do? What should you do? Bricking these devices without warning would be a bit extreme, agreed. What if you figure out a way to ensure that legitimate chips work and others fail in whatever way based on the nature of the cloning design. Is that OK. What if people could die? Not trying to be dramatic at all. Just saying that sometimes you need to be in someone else's shoes in order to understand their ecosystem and have context from which to understand their decisions. I've been using FTDI chips since they came out. I have designed products that could kill people and burn down buildings if they were to fail in certain ways. We bought these chips through proper distribution channels. Had we not or in the case of our distributors being duped by clone makers I'd much rather our devices be bricked than risk someone getting hurt. So, yeah, this is very real for me.
- pessimizer 12y ago>And you know clones are dangerous because they are unreliable, failure prone and nondeterministic in some way. Is there any evidence of this?
- conductor 12y agoHere is their response: https://twitter.com/mikelectricstuf/status/524917368154492929 https://twitter.com/mikelectricstuf/status/52491736815449292...
- icebraining 12y agoSay your chips are being used on MRI machines, cars, planes, glucose meters, ATM machines and a whole host of other mission critical systems. First, that's a red herring because most of those machines aren't running Windows, let alone with automatic updates. Second, you're essentially advocating vigilantism by corporations. If FTDI was actually concerned about the lives of people due to faulty chips - and I find this supposition laughable, but let's go with it - they could have (1) warned the users, (2) disable the driver and/or (3) contact the appropriate official institutions. A supposition that someone, somewhere might die does not justify unlawful destruction of property, and if proven that FTDI intended to brick those chips, I hope they get sued hard.
- stox 12y agoI can understand FTDI's frustration, but vigilantism is not acceptable behavior. The lawyers are going to have a feeding frenzy on this one.
- kbart 12y agoI don't get it. What's the logic behind silently killing a counterfeit chip instead of showing a pop-up window with "Unlicensed chip detected, drivers stopped." or smth? I'm sure most of the buyers of these counterfeit chips get in such situation without knowing and would be happy to return the fake chips/boards to supplier what in turn could help fighting the root cause, not just punishing the unsuspecting end users. I personally have encountered many non-working FTDI cables and blamed FTDIChip for their lousy quality control, so it not only hurts the end-users but the reputation of the legitimate company as well.