5 ms·
On the trail of the elusive successful psychopath
- zoba 12y agoI've been curious if there has been examples of psychopaths working together, presumably because it would be more optimal. Also, I'm pretty curious if/how they can identify each other.
- yuna 12y agoI have struggled (yes, struggled) with psychopathic traits for most of my life. Maybe I can provide some insight. It's hard for psychopaths work together because they don't see the value of people beyond being a means to an end. If you want an example: I would have no mental qualms with killing my friends or family if there were a tangible benefit and no repercussions. Thankfully for everyone, there are repercussions, and there should be. The problem is that a psychopath will screw you over when it's advantageous for them to do so; history, bonds, an even what most people would consider "morality" don't really factor in. Everything is just a reasoned calculation. Two psychopaths working together would require some sort of framework keeping the two from screwing each other over when the opportunity arises. In practice that's really hard to accomplish As for how you can identify a psychopath. If you could readily identify me as a psychopath you see how that would be a problem in my relationships. Nonetheless I'm certain I have brushed up against one or two. Although I liked them as people, we never clicked because were obsessed with our own domains. I appreciated how no-nonsense they were about the world and didn't let emotions affect their judgements, but I also had no interest in their schemes (though I did respect them) when I had my own schemes to worry about. If I ever marry, I don't think it will be with another psychopath.
- kazinator 12y ago> I would have no mental qualms with killing my friends What is the definition of "friends" that you're using? Presumably, people who think they are your friends, because they don't know. > Although I liked them as people ... ... you would still have killed them if there were no repercussions, and some tangible benefit. Hmm, what is the working definition of "like" here? Usually when normal people like something, a big element of what that means is wishing for its preservation. Also, how can you say "like them as people" if you don't see the value of people beyond being a means to an end? By this reasoning, your use of "like ... as people" should be synonymous with "like ... as means to and end". In that case why use the term "as people". The ordinary meaning of to "like someone as a person" is quite opposite to seeing them as a means to an end.
- delluminatus 12y agoI think it's important to recognize that the human mind is quite good at maintaining multiple contradictory beliefs. It's certainly possible to "like someone as a person", see them as a means to an end, and still be willing to murder them, even at the same time. Although this kind of compartmentalization might seem illogical -- well, it is illogical -- it's also a powerful coping mechanism.
- AnimalMuppet 12y ago> Usually when normal people like something... Yeah, that's the problem right there. You're thinking "normal", and the GP said he struggled with psychopathy. Your "normal" doesn't apply in his world.
- lomnakkus 12y agoPsychopaths don't "struggle" with psychopathy -- they either a) lack the introspection to realize that they're psychopaths, or b) just don't care. That's part and parcel of being a psychopath. I'll grant the OP "pyschopathic traits", but the rest of his/her post seems to try to support full-blown "psychopathy" rather than just "psychopathic traits". The post might be suggestive of extreme narcissim and/or attention-seeking behavior, but a real diagnosis of psychopathy would require a lot of other traits as well -- and would require an extensive (verifiable) history. See Hare's checklist.
- chmike 12y agoI must disagree. First there are different level of psychopathy making it a fuzzy set. Second I have heard of people diagnosed as psychopaths and indeed struggling to remain socially adequate in order to avoid to be caged in psychiatric hospitals. In this way cold logic is used as leverage to induce socially compatible behaviour.
- JanezStupar 12y agoFrom the anecdotal data I have read on the topic, at least the smart ones do recognize each other and do not work together for obvious reasons. A sociopath does not feel kinship and AFAIK they view themselves as predators. Another sociopath is more of competition and a potential threat.
- wellboy 12y agoIf you think about it, if you want to do a startup, you basically have to become a psychopath, because you constantly have to tell yourself that everyone who is getting a job is doing it wrong, which is 99% of people, you have to be willing to lose everything, not be afraid of anything and you have to push yourself out of the comfort zone all the time. But I think it boils down to what the core of a person is. If you are just a normal person that can emulate the behavioural patters of a psychopath, then you are a normal person. If you are a psychopath at your core, because that's how you were born and you can emulate the behavioural patterns of a normal person, you are a psychopath. While I can imagine that there are some of the latter category that start a startup,I think you need to be of the first category to make it through the entire startup grind.
- wavefunction 12y agoYou really don't have to become a psychopath to start a company. Many people do it all the time while going to school, raising a family, working other jobs... Now they may just be opening up a restaurant or dry cleaner rather than a high-tech CRUD mobile app which makes their "startup" less sexy than one run by Ivy Leaguers who swear by not-sleeping, setting dogs on fire for fun and mainlining Thai crank as their secret to success. Those people advocating for crazy off-the-wall "one weird secret" cargo-cult schemes succeeded in spite of themselves, and not because of. So really, becoming a psychopath is probably the last thing any aspiring business person should become. It won't help you balance the books. It won't bring in new business. And it won't help form and maintain lasting personal relationships that are the real secret to business success.
- yuna 12y agoNot that I agree with the grandparent's sweeping statements about psychopaths, but your comment also makes a sweeping statement that "becoming a psychopath is probably the last thing any aspiring business person should become". No evidence is provided in either case. It's also pretty insulting to both psychologists and psychopaths alike that you think a psychopath is just something you decide one day to become. It's also jarring that in one paragraph you bash crazy "one weird secrets" to success, when in the next paragraph you claim that the one weird secret to success is "personal relationships".
- to3m 12y agoThe byline - "On the trail of the successful psychopath Sarah Francis Smith, Ashley Watts and Scott Lilienfeld" - is a good, short example of the importance of punctuation.
- otakucode 12y agoHow on earth could you find it challenging to find a successful psychopath? Have you never heard of Goldman Sachs? Or what about the guy who ran Sunbeam into the ground? He is actively a self-avowed psychopath obsessed with predatory behavior.
- delluminatus 12y agoYeah, psychopaths are everywhere. Why don't they just interview <someone I dislike>? /s Seriously though, what is the point of this comment? Surely you already know that they are talking about rigorous, publishable research, not just "Goldman Sachs are evil lol".
- pasbesoin 12y agoIf I didn't respect their privacy, I could point you to one right now. In fact, figuring this out was a source of significant enlightenment for me. (Thanks, Internet!) I wouldn't describe them as an unqualified success, but they are very good at getting what they want -- and leaving the rest behind. I can't imagine that they (speaking generally) are that unusual. Separate from my own experience, and I haven't read it yet, but a relative has recommended the book, People of the Lie. I don't know whether their experience was with a psychopath, but the title grabbed my attention.
- PhantomGremlin 12y agoI've some responses about multiple posts, so rather than comment individually I'm making a general comment. First, I also think it's simple to find "a successful psychopath". Take the case of one Bernard Lawrence Madoff. Let's look at some criteria from the article: charm --- yes, clearly charmed people into "investing" with him, "charmed" his way into being the chairman of NASDAQ dishonesty --- yes, c.f. 150 year jail sentence lack of remorse --- I've never read of any on his part, have you? lack of empathy --- yes, otherwise how can you steal so many people's life savings? poor forethought --- yes, the scheme was so simplistic, so harebrained that the SEC ignored warnings, probably because no rational person would believe it! Second, as for "examples of psychopaths working together", isn't that pretty much the definition of "organized crime"? Most of their schemes are very simplistic, they certainly lack empathy for their victims, etc. Finally, I think it's too restrictive to limit the discussion to "rigorous, publishable research". How can you rigorously investigate 99% of these people? That's not possible. E.g. in Madoff's case his pathology was easily identifiable in hindsight, but researchers aren't just wandering around looking for businessmen to study. And certainly most "criminal masterminds" (gotta love that phrase) won't allow themselves to be contemporaneously "researched". Tony Soprano was the fictional counterexample, which is a big reason why that show was so charming. So "rigorous" research is pretty much limited to dead or uncooperative people. And if that's the case, just how "rigorous" is it? How do you understand Madoff's psyche without his cooperation? And yet he's clearly a psychopath. And clearly successful, seeing as he pulled it off for not years but decades.
- chmike 12y agoMadoff is not what we could call a successful psychopath.
- PhantomGremlin 12y agoI disagree. Here's Wikipedia:[1] federal investigators believe the fraud began as early as the mid-1980s and may have begun as far back as the 1970s ... The amount missing from client accounts, including fabricated gains, was almost $65 billion Bernie could have been conning people for over 30 years, and he was in his 70s when it ended. If that's not "successful", then you must agree that no Ponzi scheme can ever be successful. (Even Social Security will eventually collapse). If I were in Bernie's shoes, I think what would pain me the most is that both of my sons were dead, and that one died as a result of the Ponzi scheme (and was it really suicide?). But then again, if Bernie is really the psychopath I think he is, he might not really care about even his own children. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bernard_Madoff http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bernard_Madoff