5 ms·
The study, which is planned for the spring, is designed to include three groups of 24 women with Stage 4 breast cancer who are in stable condition and undergoin
by teekert 12y ago
The study, which is planned for the spring, is designed to include three groups of 24 women with Stage 4 breast cancer who are in stable condition and undergoing hormonal therapy. Two groups will gather at resorts in San Miguel de Allende, Mexico, under the supervision of Langer and her staff. The experimental group will live for a week in surroundings that evoke 2003, a date when all the women were healthy and hopeful, living without a mortal threat hanging over them. They will be told to try to inhabit their former selves. Few clues of the present day will be visible inside the resorts or, for that matter, outside them. In the living areas, turn-of-the-millennium magazines will be lying around, as will DVDs of films like “Titanic” and “The Big Lebowski.” San Miguel de Allende, which has historically been a place known for its nearby healing mineral springs, is a Unesco World Heritage Site, and many of its buildings look as they did a few hundred years ago. “The whole town is a time capsule,” Langer says. (The other group at San Miguel will have the support of fellow cancer patients but will not live in the past; a third group will not experience any research intervention.)
WTF.
And what happens when you had cancer in 2003 but got cured, would it come back? Better avoid The Big Lebowski in that case.
- fhnjh 12y agoIf this is a real effect, it does not necessarily involve magic. I find it quite easy to imagine an organism evolving to subtly alter it's physical state according to the function of it's nervous system. Why is it so hard to believe that the mind controls the body at a cellular level? Even if this is a magical effect, it can still be codified and brought within the bounds of scientific discourse.
- teekert 12y agoFirst of all, "evolving" happens by selective pressures and over generations on a population level. But I see what you mean, you mean changing to accommodate to the environment. But here we are not talking about tanning to compensate for increased UV exposure, we are not even talking about changing to match our environment, we are talking about reducing an illness by evoking memories of the past by physical objects. Unless this past environment was one that actually kills cancers cells (I don't know how the Big Lebowksi might do that) or perhaps reduces tumor growth I can't imagine any way how this can work. What I can imagine is going on a time out, reducing stress and thus biological stress responses does have an influence on a tumor. I hope they are compensating for this effect. They should have a control group in a reduced stress environment (or something that mimics all evironmental variables of the back-in-time room but for the back-in-time aspect) perhaps with a bluray disc of Lucy. Hey or perhaps dumbphones induce less stress. Perhaps you get better sleep in the 2003 environment, light/circadian rithm is known to influence cancer: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Risk_factors_for_breast_cancer#Light_at_night_and_disturbance_of_circadian_rhythm http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Risk_factors_for_breast_cancer#... Et cetera et cetera, et cetera
- sophacles 12y agoEvolve is a word much older than Darwin. It means "develop gradually". My opinion can evolve. My code can evolve. My body can evolve. It does not now, nor has it ever, meant strictly the biological notion you limited it to above. The GP post used the word correctly.
- comicjk 12y agoIf I assert that a man runs, I might mean that he flows under pressure, but you would probably interpret me to mean that he moves quickly on his feet. "An organism evolving" similarly tends toward one particular meaning. When you then say you mean to be "within the bounds of scientific discourse," how can you blame someone for thinking you are using the scientific definition?
- sophacles 12y agoWhen you then say you mean to be "within the bounds of scientific discourse," I said no such thing. I am not the person who used the word "evolve". I merely am capable of understanding that sometimes pedantry doesn't actually help anything.
- saraid216 12y agoSo why did you respond to pedantry with more pedantry?
- mrqwerty 12y agoEvolve means gradual change to me. For the more sophisticated amongst us, we are able to take the root meaning of the word and understand it's implication in different contexts.
- sophacles 12y agoMy statement sometimes pedantry doesn't actually help anything implies that sometimes it does help things. IMO this was one of those occasions.
- phkahler 12y ago>> Why is it so hard to believe that the mind controls the body at a cellular level? Because modern medicine (and science) does not like to believe anything that it has no explanation for. You can show not only correlations, but causative action and a lot of people will reject the finding if it is unintuitive and has no known mechanism. IMHO this has become a problem. Even though we claim science starts with observation, people still don't believe what is in front of them unless they have something conceptual to hang it on.
- darkmighty 12y agoAn important remark, but let me remind you that scientists are used to the 90% of the times where the current models are correct but observations/experiments are erroneous, specially when things deviate so much from known models. Of course, the 10% of times the models can't explain the observation are indeed crucial to science.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- collyw 12y agoIt is well known that stress can alter hormone levels as well as many other negative physiological effects. That seems like the mind controlling the body. Every movement you make is the mind altering the body via the nervous system if you want to be pedantic about it.
- kazinator 12y ago> Why is it so hard to believe that the mind controls the body at a cellular level? It does, obviously. Contracting a voluntary muscle requires work that is done at the cellular level. A signal travels from the brain and ends up translated into a chemical message at the cellular level which contracts muscle fibers. The brain is even able to address a specific set of cells that correspond to a bundle of specific nerve fibers for that muscle. Nervous-system signaling involves the cellular level: changing electric potentials, ions flowing across cell membranes, and and such.
- mrqwerty 12y agoYes I had this in my mind when I wrote the above post. I was trying to draw your attention to the fact that we already believe such things. (Two different accounts, two different pcs, lost password)
- mattstreet 12y agoYou would think that if a person's perceptions and belief could grant a much longer life span, at least one crazy person would have provided this by living to something like 200.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- septerr 12y agoI think it will be close to impossible to make the participants feel like it is 2003 by doing things like placing turn-of-the century magazines around etc. It sounds silly. It almost seems to be mocking their intelligence (I know that's not what they are doing). IMO, they should stick to just telling these participants to try and put themselves in the mindset they were in before they ever faced cancer.
- organsnyder 12y agoThat's the whole point of the studies, though—they made people feel younger by doing everything possible to make it feel like they had stepped back in time. The placebo effect is more complex than, intuitively, it should be. Otherwise, all you'd need to do was explain the placebo effect to someone, and the belief in the placebo effect itself would effect the desired results (in effect, the placebo effect would be the placebo<g>). Instead, we need to do tricks—sugar pills, simulated environments—to get it to work. It really defies reason.
- codyb 12y agoI'm not sure it defies reason. If you take a child and place him in a blank room and tell him to play, they will have trouble playing and will get bored. If you take that same child and place them in a room with a bunch of complex toys they will probably use those toys in pretty normal ways. But if you take a child and put them in a place where there aren't "traditional" toys (toys they're used to, objects marketed as toys) they will use their imaginations to make a block of wood a car, or a house, or something else. So in that same sense, if you take an adult and tell them to imagine it is 2003 in a blank room it's going to be difficult. And if you do the same in a room that is filled with things from today it will also be difficult because they will be trying to force objects from post 2003 to fit into a 2003 mindset. But finally, if you put them in a room filled with things from 2003 they will be able to use their imaginations much more effectively to enter a 2003 mindset. For the record, these are just my thoughts on the matter.
- saulrh 12y ago> and the belief in the placebo effect itself would effect the desired results Are there any studies saying that this precise trick, consciously invoked by people who understand the situation, doesn't work?
- tokenadult 12y agoIf the experiment reliably produces the effect that they are investigating, then they have at least a million dollars in their future. http://web.randi.org/the-million-dollar-challenge.html http://web.randi.org/the-million-dollar-challenge.html But the sample size planned for this study is tiny, and the study won't really have the statistical power to demonstrate a true effect, even if the groups differ in outcomes (which I rather doubt they will). AFTER EDIT: I see a downvote, presumably indicating disagreement, has come in. It would be a courtesy to onlookers here (and to me, for that matter) to explain what part of my comment you disagree with, if you please. To be clear, I genuinely think, based on much reading of medical research, that the effect the investigators are looking for will not be found as a replicable effect, even if their preliminary low-n study shows a difference in outcomes among the different study groups. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, and to claim that tricking people into thinking they live at an earlier time will reverse the disease progression of cancer is to make an extraordinary claim (which is why I think this claim may be within the scope of the James Randi paranormal challenge). P.S. Has any onlooker calculated how large a difference in outcomes would have to be observed in a study with only 24 participants in each group to convincingly show that the treatment effect is genuine? Statistical power is an issue that is often neglected in published preliminary research.
- T-hawk 12y agoIs this the sort of thing that's in the scope of JREF's challenge? It says "psychic, supernatural, or paranormal ability". If this experiment does show a result from manipulating mental age with a throwback environment, we wouldn't assume that result derived from a paranormal cause. It would be a new psychosomatic effect where the mind can affect the body, but it would be through normal biological and chemical means, not the supernatural evidence JREF is looking for.
- kemayo 12y agoYeah, it sounds like this is talking about (effectively) a variant on the placebo effect.
- Strilanc 12y ago
- kristopolous 12y agobest argument to use seamonkey I've ever seen.