5 ms·
It seems like a crazy ruling to me because it is basically impossible to communicate quickly for farther than about 100 yards on a calm day without enlisting th
by snowwrestler 12y ago
It seems like a crazy ruling to me because it is basically impossible to communicate quickly for farther than about 100 yards on a calm day without enlisting the assistance of a third party.
Does this imply that most people have no expectation of privacy in their communications? Their phone calls? Their emails? Their letters? I find that hard to believe.
- arh68 12y agoIt's a lot like handing over your rolls of film to be developed to the teenager at CVS. Discreet. If you voluntarily conveyed the information, you've got a poor claim to privacy in light of Smith v Maryland.
- nmcfarl 12y agoSnowwrestlers point is interesting, why is a warrant needed for a phone tap? You are clearly enlisting a 3rd parties help, and I think the general public knows that their phone company can listen in on their calls... People are clearly sharing the content of the call as much as the number with the Telco. It seems odd that there are 2 standards here, particularly as it's the same transaction.
- daxelrod 12y agoA warrant is needed because there are explicit wiretapping laws that protect the content of phone communication. This was not a legal principle that was bootstrapped from an interpretation of the fourth amendment.
- snowwrestler 12y agoThere may be explicit laws for wiretapping phones, but the expectation of privacy in email does rest on the 4th Amendment. Here's an example of a ruling on emails that are held by a 3rd party: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2010/12/breaking-news-eff-victory-appeals-court-holds https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2010/12/breaking-news-eff-vict... So there does seem to be a weird double standard in the "3rd party doctrine" between content and routing information. I think if you asked 100 people on a random street what part of email they expect to be private, almost everyone would answer "all of it." I agree with the EFF that the Smith ruling is outdated. edit: clarity
- snowwrestler 12y agoBut how many people know about Smith v. Maryland? If you went back in time and asked people if they thought they gave up privacy when they dropped off their film, they would say "hell no." Especially since photo lab workers were prosecuted for doing things like keeping copies of photos they like.
- anigbrowl 12y agoYou could write someone a letter without putting your name on the outside - this is why I made the point about it being the price of convenience. The content of your conversation is legally something else again.
- snowwrestler 12y agoBut there is no way to do that with an email or a phone call. Their metadata and content are stored the same way by the same 3rd party. So why would there be separate legal treatments?