3 ms·
I agree with you, but this also doesn't seem (in my totally amateur reading) to actually be covered by the 4th amendment. If we really want this sort of privacy
by sanderjd 12y ago
I agree with you, but this also doesn't seem (in my totally amateur reading) to actually be covered by the 4th amendment. If we really want this sort of privacy enshrined, we could really use a new amendment. It should be unsurprising that huge changes in society, like those of the internet age, would require fundamental changes to the Constitution - this is what amendments are for. This idea is laughably impractical though, which either suggests that amendments were made too difficult to achieve, or that the system is working well by making us wait for overwhelming consensus on the question.
- AnthonyMouse 12y ago> I agree with you, but this also doesn't seem (in my totally amateur reading) to actually be covered by the 4th amendment. If we really want this sort of privacy enshrined, we could really use a new amendment. The First Amendment read literally would disallow laws against libel or copyright infringement or even fraud. On the other hand, read literally it would only protect "freedom of speech, or of the press" and provide no protection for electronic communications because they aren't spoken or printed. Literal readings are not useful. There is very little a pro-privacy amendment would accomplish that couldn't reasonably be read into the first, fourth and fifth amendments already. The problem is not the constitutional language, the problem is what the courts are letting the government get away with.
- sanderjd 12y agoI'm not suggesting that the amendments should be read literally, I'm suggesting that in this particular case there is very reasonable difference of opinion about what should and shouldn't constitute people's papers, effects, and private property for the purposes of federal law, and it could use to be cleared up by people who are elected.
- AnthonyMouse 12y agoThere is always a very reasonable difference of opinion about what a given constitutional provision actually means. The reason amending the constitution is hard is that it's meant to act as a check on "people who are elected." Take a look at the amendments since the bill of rights. 11: Sovereign immunity for states 12, 15, 17, 19, 20, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27: Changes to voting rights, elections and issues related to elected officials 13: Abolish slavery 14: Post civil war amendment, reduction in power of the states, new enforcement powers for federal government 16: Grants Congress the power to levy income tax 18: Prohibition (repealed by 21) Congress hasn't voted to meaningfully reduce federal power in over 200 years.
- sanderjd 12y agoNot always, but sure, often. That doesn't mean it is pointless to ever bother writing anything down. Just like the difficulty of passing an amendment is a check on the legislature's ability to grant themselves more power, the possibility of doing so is a check on the judiciary's ability to make laws mean whatever the current court wants them to mean. But if your point is that privacy advocates have a better chance of success through the avenue of a broad interpretation of the fourth and fifth amendments than through a new amendment that puts a broader interpretation in the actual text, then it is a point well taken. They may well prefer to pass the opposite law, based on their historical action.