2 ms·
I realize I didn't provide much to take hold of, but this is what I meant by the line that you quoted: By "democracy" I have in mind what Americans and Western
by leephillips 12y ago
I realize I didn't provide much to take hold of, but this is what I meant by the line that you quoted:
By "democracy" I have in mind what Americans and Western Europeans mean by democracy, which is decidedly not a simple tyranny of the majority enacted through voting. Democracy in any meaningful sense has some means of self regulation that preserves certain rights and perpetuates self-determination for future generations.
I'm not blaming the process. The U.S. still has a serviceable democracy despite the drug war and all the other examples of bad public policy that are desired by the people. Our democracy has even survived the violation of parts of the constitution that makes it possible. My point was that no democracy can exist in any meaningful sense in a society that has criminalized the discussion of ideas and the expression of opinions. Once that line has been crossed it is not a matter of undesirable public policy, but of democracy eating itself. Surely you agree that there can be no democracy if you're not allowed to talk about how people should vote.
India has become a place where you can be jailed for exposing the physical cause of a weeping statue because you've hurt the feelings of the Catholics who want to believe that it's a miracle. I don't believe democracy can exist under such conditions, but I hope things change soon for this great nation.
- rayiner 12y agoWe may be arguing semantics at this point, but to me philosopher kings sitting in judgment of the popular will exemplifies less democracy, not more.