4 ms·
Yup. The way I like to express this is as follows - It took Einstein about 10 years to formulate the general theory of relativity, needing no further experimen
by sriku 12y ago
Yup. The way I like to express this is as follows -
It took Einstein about 10 years to formulate the general theory of relativity, needing no further experimental input into the work during this period. A few other scientists such as Wheeler, Schwarzschild and others, not to mention mathematicians like Riemann, put in at least as many "top scientist years" of time - about 20 TSYs in all, conservatively. The core content of this is taught in grad school these days over one semester and could be considered about 1/2 grad student years worth of intellectual effort.
So what did these people do for the remaining 19.5/20 of the time? They got hold of a problem that wouldnt let go of them, that they poorly understood, but nevertheless persevered through false starts, uglifications, and what not to arrive finally at the beautiful theory that it is.
i.e. Problem finding and perseverence through foggy days with all but a candle that seems to threaten to blow out any minute is at least 40x harder and that much more valuable than problem solving.
I believe your phd would've served you well on that front.
- titanomachy 12y ago> needing no further experimental work General relativity is an incredibly impressive theory, even more so when you take into account how few experimental observations were required to formulate it. Basically "the speed of light is the same in any frame of reference" and "being in a gravitational field is (locally) indistinguishable from being in an accelerated reference frame". (For the second one, think about being in a rocket ship accelerating at a constant rate... you feel a force pushing you into the floor, just like you would if you were standing on the Earth's surface.) If those two things are true, then GR is the only logical conclusion... but we might have gone another 100 years without reaching that conclusion if it hadn't been for Einstein.