3 ms·
I think she's missed the obvious. Employers want the McDonald's system, where the brilliance is in the system, not the employees. If it's in the worker, it's
by CapitalistCartr 12y ago
I think she's missed the obvious. Employers want the McDonald's system, where the brilliance is in the system, not the employees. If it's in the worker, it's perishable; in the system, it's not. When I hire a machine operator, brilliance isn't a useful asset, so I'm not paying for it. Some brains, yes, sure, but not above a 120 IQ. That's all the job requires, and I keep it structured that way.
- fapjacks 12y agoThis is an incredibly insightful comment that I think many, many people don't see when trying to explain certain phenomena in the business world.
- dkarapetyan 12y agoIs this really the assumption you operate with? I'm not trying to sound condescending because this is pretty much what I observed at a certain major tech company. The whole thing wasn't very far from a giant meat factory and it was exactly why there hadn't been any innovation in decades. You can argue that if your business model is so good that you don't need to innovate to stay in business then by all means milk it for what it's worth but that doesn't feel like a long-term strategy. Microsoft and friends have R&D departments that rival the best research institutions in the world and they pay a premium for it. If some of that was a natural byproduct of their core business operations then maybe they wouldn't need to pay a premium for it.
- lotharbot 12y agoIt's close to the assumption I operate with. For a sufficiently large business, it's important to be stable/robust -- that is, to be able to withstand change. A business that's heavily reliant on individual brilliance across the board has the disadvantage of potentially collapsing if enough brilliant people leave without training equally brilliant replacements. Yes, you want some brilliant people specifically in R&D / innovation. You want brilliant people overseeing the entire system. Brilliant people in key positions might improve your overall efficiency by an order of magnitude on a particular project -- but you don't want the whole project to fall apart just because Joe moved out of state or Jane went on long-term maternity leave or Jake was hit by a bus. Microsoft does have a world-class R&D department, but they also have a lot of average code monkeys and average janitors and average HR people.
- incision 12y agoExactly. It's easy enough to understand this applied to fast food, but I get the impression other industries would rather not believe it to be true. Thing is, I think it's clearly evidenced in tech by every "I went through two days of interviewing on algorithms and distributed systems to hack on PHP boilerplate?" story. Tech might go to the trouble to select for brilliance, but they aren't necessarily using or paying for it. Further it's readily admitted by folks like a16z [1]. "Thus software itself becomes the driving force of leveling the ability to write software to solve problems. This is a good thing: As software becomes a high-impact, low-skill trade, we decouple the technical ability and experience needed to write tricky software from the ability to solve problems for people." 1: http://a16z.com/2014/07/30/the-happy-demise-of-the-10x-engineer/ http://a16z.com/2014/07/30/the-happy-demise-of-the-10x-engin...
- kashkhan 12y agoEmployees also want predictability where the pay comes from the system and not from your direct boss. Bosses are perishable and the system is not. Anyone who choose to take a job accepts this. Real brilliance - creativity - requires you to embrace the unpredictable. That section of society are the inventors, who are willing to face long odds and do what they want. The system works only for its survival. It is not interested in giving you a wholesome life.
- pyfish 12y agoGood point. This is why a healthy and educated populace is bad for the economy. Merica!
- gitaarik 12y agoYes that sounds very logical. In the end this is probably true for every job on every level. For example, as a programmer it's good to have a high IQ, but if it's too high you might not fit in the company anymore.