3 ms·
> At the most fundamental level, you want the bullets to dump their energy in the target body. "Regular", as in Full Metal Jacket (FMJ) bullets are smooth and s
by r00fus 12y ago
> At the most fundamental level, you want the bullets to dump their energy in the target body. "Regular", as in Full Metal Jacket (FMJ) bullets are smooth and slippery, and more readily pass through a body (and are more likely to cause greater harm to anyone behind).
When I served in the military, it was common understanding that Hague convention required use of "ball ammunition" was desirable because you want to inflict casualties on your opposition, not necessarily to kill them.
From what I was told, a soldier wounded in service to a proper enemy army is useful to you because it takes a lot of people and effort to rescue, resuscitate and rehabilitate the wounded soldier than one you simply kill. Also having a screaming squad-mate does impact morale downwards too.
Of course, all that reasoning could break down when dealing with irregulars and guerrilla warfare, but possibly not.
In no way is it "Absolutely and totally false."
- hga 12y agoHere you're confusing war time operations, where for example you may only get one hit on a target due to him being distant or whatever, and deliberate killing is most certainly allowed, vs. what is ostensibly a peace time police style operation. In the latter, an order to kill the targets no matter what is likely to be illegal (but in a case like this arguably a matter of foreign policy). What ammo is used it likely to be a lot less important than how it's employed. For example, per one account a number of them were hosed down with machine guns, and the only hollow point ammo used, or plausibly used (since it doesn't tend to work well in semi-auto or full auto weapons unless they were designed or modified for it) was in .357 revolvers used by the close combat team. And strangely enough, 3 survived.... As for the Hague convention, I haven't studied it and its genesis in any detail, but the general idea was to make war less barbaric. Whatever is later said to troops who for political reasons are required to use much less effective ammo that's much more likely to get them killed is at minimum suspect. E.g. logically taking someone you shoot out of the war altogether, by killing or maiming them, is vastly superior to their coming back after convalescence.
- phil21 12y ago> logically taking someone you shoot out of the war altogether, by killing or maiming them, is vastly superior to their coming back after convalescence. Strongly disagree, as do at least a few military strategists throughout history. I suppose it depends on who you're fighting (if you're fighting a ruthless Ghengis Khan all bets are probably off), but for Hague convention signees in general they will put a high priority on taking care of their wounded. In fact anti-personnel landmines are generally designed to maim, not kill, for this reason. It costs far more to take care of that soldier who got his leg blown off from the knee below, than it does to bury him. Both in time, material, logistics, and possibly morale. So yes - if I'm in an all-out war, I'm going to want to significantly maim (as in make them incapable of fighting for an extended period of time and require extensive logistics to keep alive) a large portion of the enemy. This soaks up even more resources on their side to take care of them and only a certain percentage of those will return to the fight.
- Perdition 12y ago>When I served in the military, it was common understanding that Hague convention required use of "ball ammunition" was desirable because you want to inflict casualties on your opposition, not necessarily to kill them. It was also probably common understanding that the Sergeant Major ate misbehaving enlisted men for breakfast. That is just a barracks room tale, similar to the one that .50 BMG can only legally be used on material and not personnel (which you can allegedly get around by aiming at the enemies web gear or helmet). The Hague convention banned hollow points because they were thought to be cruel and unnecessary. The convention continues to largely be obeyed because in general military use ball ammunition is better (eg it can shoot through light cover without deforming) and cheaper.