4 ms·
The standard monopsony effect is on quality. Monopsonies push the price below the cost of production, so producers cut production costs to an unreasonable leve
by bryanlarsen 12y ago
The standard monopsony effect is on quality. Monopsonies push the price below the cost of production, so producers cut production costs to an unreasonable level.
In the case of books, you'd see that by cuts in editing, by authors shortening the amount of time that they spend writing a book, and through authors dropping out and leaving the field to less talented writers with fewer alternative income sources.
The textbook monopsony is government health care. Most visibly, the long wait times for some health care services.
- slowmovintarget 12y agoExcept Amazon is arguing for a lower price because it will increase sales and make both Amazon and the publisher more money. They aren't asking for more books or less editing. They're trying to make everyone more money. Worse, the argument is over pricing on e-books, not physical stock, so Hachette's stance makes even less sense. As usual, Paul Krugman sees everything through a political lens, so naturally Amazon is evil and must be beaten down.
- bryanlarsen 12y agoLower prices increase sales and profits for Amazon because they compete against book stores. Lower prices decrease profits for book publishers who make money both from Amazon and book stores.
- panarky 12y agoAs another author and Nobel laureate said[1], "everything is politics". If the lower price really would make more money for everyone, then surely Hachette would readily do it. Since they don't, and since they understand this market as well as anyone, a reasonable person might assume that they would indeed make less money with a lower price. Even free-market fundamentalists must see that free markets don't function when dominated by monopoly or monopsony. So isn't there a legitimate public policy question about whether the state should limit that market power? [1] http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Thomas_Mann http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Thomas_Mann
- icelancer 12y ago>In the case of books, you'd see that by cuts in editing, by authors shortening the amount of time that they spend writing a book, and through authors dropping out and leaving the field to less talented writers with fewer alternative income sources. I just spent $10,000 editing and producing my latest book that's going to be self-published. Comparing the royalties I'll get with self-publish (not using CreateSpace BTW, though I have no problem with them) including those fees - not even half of which would be picked up by a publisher, mind you - with a publisher who absorbs ALL of my editing/producing costs is STILL a joke. Publishers are predatory towards anyone but the somewhat-ready-to-breakout writers. They do nothing for the established writer except salve his ego and they do nothing for the startup writer who begs for help.
- HelloMcFly 12y agoI'm not a writer, so I'll defer to you on that perspective. As a reader, I love publishers and editors. I've waded into the self-published world more than most, and I don't see myself buying self-published work again in the future without significant (outlier-level) crowd-sourced reviews like Wool or The Martian.
- icelancer 12y agoI don't blame you. Most self-published stuff is garbage. ... Have you noticed that most PUBLISHED stuff is garbage, too?
- HelloMcFly 12y agoI have noticed that the proportional amount of garbage is lower among published works, and that the resulting breadth of content is much easier to wade through to find quality content.
- Shamanmuni 12y agoIt's not just a matter of how much money the writer will get. And even when talking about that, you assume that any published book will sell, and that's not true. When you publish through a publishing house, they assume the financial risk. I hope you get back your $10.000 (and much more), but it surely is not a given, most books don't sell much. It's the same situation we have with startups and VC's, the publisher can never be sure if a book by a small author will succeed before it's on the market. It's always a gamble. So they even those who succeed with those who don't. And more important, to many new and more established writers, the editors in publishing houses provide serious value in the form of advice and guidance. It's easy to think that because you read books you surely know how to write a good one. But that's similar to thinking that because you use applications you surely know how to code a good one. And lastly, good publishing houses serve as brands for consumers. People won't see a self-published technology book with the same eyes as if it was published by O'Reilly (for example). From past experiences they probably feel guaranteed of a certain level of quality from the O'Reilly book that a small lone author almost never can provide I'm not claiming that the publishing system is a panacea or that all editors are amazing. But you described it as mostly useless, bordering on a ripoff, and I think it's far from the truth.