4 ms·
The main point isn't one action or another but, and Krugman says it clearly, that Amazon has too much power. Modern democracies usually strive to prevent conce
by pron 12y ago
The main point isn't one action or another but, and Krugman says it clearly, that Amazon has too much power.
Modern democracies usually strive to prevent concentration of power in few hands, especially if those hands aren't elected. The market, however, does often favor concentration of power, and when that happens, democracies should protect themselves.
The US in particular has had a history of businesses gaining too much power and seriously hurting the public. This is Krugman's main point:
[Y]es, I have Amazon Prime and use it a lot. But again, so what? The desirability of new technology, or even Amazon’s effective use of that technology, is not the issue. After all, John D. Rockefeller and his associates were pretty good at the oil business, too — but Standard Oil nonetheless had too much power, and public action to curb that power was essential... The robber baron era ended when we as a nation decided that some business tactics were out of line. And the question is whether we want to go back on that decision.
Personally I think that exploitative practices by big business are making a huge comeback, in Silicon Valley in particular (see Google with privacy, Uber with workers, the SV non-poaching cartel and more). It is interesting to compare and contrast this with the Gilded Age robber barons. It's certainly not the same, but the robber barons are coming back, albeit in a new form.
- WalterBright 12y agoI read Rockefeller's biography "Titan" and could not find a single instance in it where Standard Oil's large market share "seriously hurt" the public. S.O. was a serious force in reducing the price of kerosene to the public - by 70%.
- pron 12y agoDid you skip the part where he (and his ilk) enslaved a large portion of the country in all but name? Or the part where the people begged government to help curb the robber barons, and Teddy Roosevelt wrestled power away from them?
- WalterBright 12y ago> he (and his ilk) enslaved a large portion of the country I read the book, and would be most interested in a cite for this. > the people begged government to help curb the robber barons, True, but that's not a statement the public was seriously harmed. > Teddy Roosevelt wrestled power away from them True, but also not a statement that the public was seriously harmed. It's possible that "Titan" is a whitewash, but it has 4.5 stars on Amazon and appears to be well regarded.
- johnm111888 12y agoI would argue that capitalism does not favor this "concentration of power," in fact quite the opposite. Most industries where there is huge concentration of power (i.e. banks) is largely due to regulation. These new SV companies disrupted other big businesses and will eventually be disrupted by another wave of businesses themselves. A look at the top 10 companies by market cap in 1995 is probably very different than the top 10 currently. I'm not sure how you site "exploitative practices by big business" then give an example of Uber. Uber is % of cab services? I would not classify them as big business. And while you might have a point with Google and privacy, users are not their customer but rather their product they sell to advertisers. So to argue they use exploitative practices and comparing to Amazon is weak considering the users aren't really a part of the supply chain but rather opt-in voluntarily.
- cbd1984 12y ago> I would argue that capitalism does not favor this "concentration of power," in fact quite the opposite. That's nice and all, but history says otherwise, with the Gilded Age as the primary example: Monopolies existed in the relative regulatory vacuum, and it took government power to break them up.
- johnm111888 12y agoReferencing the time period in which the economy grew at its fastest rate in history in regards to GDP and real wages? Gilded Age transformed US into the economic superpower that it is today -- regulatory vacuum helped this. Government corruption and high tariffs helped prevent competition and helped establish the monopolies it later set out to break up. RRs benefitted from the creation of the interstate commerce commission
- cbd1984 12y ago> Referencing the time period in which the economy grew at its fastest rate in history in regards to GDP and real wages? Gilded Age transformed US into the economic superpower that it is today -- regulatory vacuum helped this. It optimized for massive growth at the expense of everything else, yes. That's not what most people actually want. Most people understand they aren't going to be Vanderbilts. > Government corruption and high tariffs helped prevent competition and helped establish the monopolies it later set out to break up. RRs benefitted from the creation of the interstate commerce commission So government did everything wrong and businesses did everything good, then and always, for ever and ever, amen. And you Austrian-School Libertarians wonder why nobody takes you seriously. More to the point, do you not understand the economic benefits of massive vertical and horizontal integration, and how difficult it is to break into a field like railroads, even if we do posit a total regulatory vacuum?