12 ms·
I normally love Krugman, but it seems like he skipped a step here. Amazon is squeezing publishers to push prices down, which is bad becuase... why? I mean, th
by ajross 12y ago
I normally love Krugman, but it seems like he skipped a step here. Amazon is squeezing publishers to push prices down, which is bad becuase... why?
I mean, the apocalyptic end game here is that publishers are forced out of business entirely and Amazon ends up buying content directly from authors, I guess. That doesn't sound so bad to me, nor like something that's going to "hurt America". Maybe then they might squeeze authors too, though that seems like something publishers are already able to do today, no?
What's the critical function provided by publishing houses that Amazon is in danger of disrupting?
- bryanlarsen 12y agoThe standard monopsony effect is on quality. Monopsonies push the price below the cost of production, so producers cut production costs to an unreasonable level. In the case of books, you'd see that by cuts in editing, by authors shortening the amount of time that they spend writing a book, and through authors dropping out and leaving the field to less talented writers with fewer alternative income sources. The textbook monopsony is government health care. Most visibly, the long wait times for some health care services.
- slowmovintarget 12y agoExcept Amazon is arguing for a lower price because it will increase sales and make both Amazon and the publisher more money. They aren't asking for more books or less editing. They're trying to make everyone more money. Worse, the argument is over pricing on e-books, not physical stock, so Hachette's stance makes even less sense. As usual, Paul Krugman sees everything through a political lens, so naturally Amazon is evil and must be beaten down.
- bryanlarsen 12y agoLower prices increase sales and profits for Amazon because they compete against book stores. Lower prices decrease profits for book publishers who make money both from Amazon and book stores.
- panarky 12y agoAs another author and Nobel laureate said[1], "everything is politics". If the lower price really would make more money for everyone, then surely Hachette would readily do it. Since they don't, and since they understand this market as well as anyone, a reasonable person might assume that they would indeed make less money with a lower price. Even free-market fundamentalists must see that free markets don't function when dominated by monopoly or monopsony. So isn't there a legitimate public policy question about whether the state should limit that market power? [1] http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Thomas_Mann http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Thomas_Mann
- icelancer 12y ago>In the case of books, you'd see that by cuts in editing, by authors shortening the amount of time that they spend writing a book, and through authors dropping out and leaving the field to less talented writers with fewer alternative income sources. I just spent $10,000 editing and producing my latest book that's going to be self-published. Comparing the royalties I'll get with self-publish (not using CreateSpace BTW, though I have no problem with them) including those fees - not even half of which would be picked up by a publisher, mind you - with a publisher who absorbs ALL of my editing/producing costs is STILL a joke. Publishers are predatory towards anyone but the somewhat-ready-to-breakout writers. They do nothing for the established writer except salve his ego and they do nothing for the startup writer who begs for help.
- HelloMcFly 12y agoI'm not a writer, so I'll defer to you on that perspective. As a reader, I love publishers and editors. I've waded into the self-published world more than most, and I don't see myself buying self-published work again in the future without significant (outlier-level) crowd-sourced reviews like Wool or The Martian.
- icelancer 12y agoI don't blame you. Most self-published stuff is garbage. ... Have you noticed that most PUBLISHED stuff is garbage, too?
- HelloMcFly 12y agoI have noticed that the proportional amount of garbage is lower among published works, and that the resulting breadth of content is much easier to wade through to find quality content.
- Shamanmuni 12y agoIt's not just a matter of how much money the writer will get. And even when talking about that, you assume that any published book will sell, and that's not true. When you publish through a publishing house, they assume the financial risk. I hope you get back your $10.000 (and much more), but it surely is not a given, most books don't sell much. It's the same situation we have with startups and VC's, the publisher can never be sure if a book by a small author will succeed before it's on the market. It's always a gamble. So they even those who succeed with those who don't. And more important, to many new and more established writers, the editors in publishing houses provide serious value in the form of advice and guidance. It's easy to think that because you read books you surely know how to write a good one. But that's similar to thinking that because you use applications you surely know how to code a good one. And lastly, good publishing houses serve as brands for consumers. People won't see a self-published technology book with the same eyes as if it was published by O'Reilly (for example). From past experiences they probably feel guaranteed of a certain level of quality from the O'Reilly book that a small lone author almost never can provide I'm not claiming that the publishing system is a panacea or that all editors are amazing. But you described it as mostly useless, bordering on a ripoff, and I think it's far from the truth.
- justincormack 12y agoOnce the publishing companies are gone it is millions of authors selling to Amazon, classic monopsony. The competitive solution is millions of authors selling direct to billions of consumers without a powerful intermediary. Whether the current situation with extra ineffectual intermediaries is much better I am not sure, probably not.
- ajross 12y agoRight, but that's sort of a semantic answer: I know (well, OK, I looked up) what monosony means. I just don't see the argument, specific to publishing, that it's such a terrible thing. Having a single buyer of a commodity good is bad, but books aren't commodities. Basically right now book authors, to first approximation, get paid basically nothing. But a few are huge successes with the ability essentially to set their own price. Amazon can't squeeze Joe-nature-book-writer any more than his publisher does already. But could even Amazon squeeze J. K. Rowling? I doubt it. I just don't see the path to this argument. Needs numbers or something.
- justincormack 12y agoOK say compare with the market for wine which sells at a similar price but has a much less centralized selling system but similarish diversity of product. With competition there is little space for 30% margins but there is still room for retail to take some margin. It is not a hugely profitable business but there are good niches.
- davidiach 12y agoThat is exactly what I was thinking. Why should I worry that Amazon makes publishers sell their books for lower prices? No explanation is offered...
- amrrs 12y agoBecause what if they repeat the same trick towards Customers? Do we have a choice then?
- icebraining 12y agoWhy wouldn't we? There are hundreds of companies selling books, and you can start a new one with essentially nothing. Book selling is not a natural monopoly which requires heavy investment to enter into. I see no reason to assume Amazon can keep a monopoly with high prices simply because they squeezed the publishers. Low prices is what keeps them in power. (Btw, I'm playing Devil's advocate here. I don't buy at Amazon for ethical reasons - I just don't find their purchasing power to be a problem)
- spacefight 12y ago> I don't buy at Amazon for ethical reasons What's the reason in your case? I genuinely wonder - considering dumping them too.
- icebraining 12y agoNothing too specific, I'm afraid; the treatment of workers, the Kindle remote deletion, the one-click patent, cutting off Wikileaks. This combined with my general dislike of very large companies (notwithstanding my pro-Google bias).
- k-mcgrady 12y ago>> "Why wouldn't we? There are hundreds of companies selling books, and you can start a new one with essentially nothing." If Amazon screws the publishers out of business and begins publishing themselves our alternatives to Amazon would be reduced significantly. Then they have the power to increase prices for consumers because there's very little we can do. We can still use libraries and book shops but for new releases published by Amazon they could make themselves sole distributor.
- danbruc 12y agoSomebody has to pay (almost) always - you raise your prices, your customers pay, you lower your prices, your employees or suppliers pay. It's not about hurting or not hurting but about distributing the pain well.
- higherpurpose 12y agoI don't. He's usually very clueless about technology, even about the economics of technology, yet he loves to ramble about it nonetheless.
- harmegido 12y agoSo you think it's good that authors get gouged on the price they can sell their services for? I bet you were cool with Google conspiring to lower the wages they could offer their employees too.
- JumpCrisscross 12y agoThe textbook answer to why monopsony is unhealthy is monopsony suppresses investment in production. In this case, the risk is dissuading authors from writing by suppressing their earnings. Imagine a simplified supply chain: authors distribute through Amazon to reach readers. Amazon exerting pricing pressure on authors benefits readers in the short term by reducing their reading costs. But by reducing authors' profits, Amazon dissuades new entry. Authors with skills elsewhere write less; the diversity and quality of new books suffers. Monopsony, when it reduces producer profits below equilibrium (e.g. what these authors would earn with many Amazons fighting for their business), dissuades investment in production. Reality is complicated by the middleman, publishers. Now we have authors contracting with publishers to distribute through Amazon to reach readers. There are multiple publishers competing for authors, so for now the authors don't appear to be squeezed as much as the middleman. Authors' continued use of publishers hints at the value of their services, which may be nothing more than collective bargaining. Removing legacy middlemen is healthy. Skewing producers' bargaining rights is not. Disentangling publishers' rents (the fraction of publishers' profits which come from them being, before Amazon, authors' only choice for distribution) from authors' costs of production (what good authors need to be paid to compensate them for the time, skill and risk which goes into writing) is difficult.
- nsomaru 12y agoA part of me welcomes this. I am sick of the noise. Browsing the Amazon (Kindle) bookstore, I wish that 90% of the junk didn't even appear in my search results. Rather read works by people who are creating for the sake of art, and not money. This does not mean that I believe authors should not be correctly compensated, but has more to do with the impetus for action itself and the resulting quality of work that is produced.
- Perdition 12y ago>A part of me welcomes this. I am sick of the noise. Browsing the Amazon (Kindle) bookstore, I wish that 90% of the junk didn't even appear in my search results. >Rather read works by people who are creating for the sake of art, and not money. What does that have to do with the low quality of many self-published works? There is tons of fiction out there written entirely for 'art' and it is nearly all complete trash. There is so much trash on Amazon because they are killing publishers who traditionally filtered out most of the trash. For every crappy bestseller they published the publishers weeded out tens of thousands of other crappy works. Crappy authors will still write, even if only for public praise (some people do like rubbish).
- raverbashing 12y ago> What's the critical function provided by publishing houses that Amazon is in danger of disrupting? Editors Having a "everybody can publish anything" model is great. But it doesn't fit all cases. Yes, an editor is really helpful. Revision, pagesetting, etc, as well.
- JumpCrisscross 12y ago> an editor is really helpful. Revision, pagesetting, etc, as well. At what point could this function be largely automated? At what point fully? Algorithmic editing brings up novel possibilities. You could have footnotes added as information is corroborated or countered. Editions could be instantly localised for almost every language and cultures. One may even get to on-the-go re-editing for individual readers (for example, I may prefer a punchier writing style with non-referential footnotes inserted in-line). This changes what a "book" is, but so did paperback publishing and the Kindle.
- fidotron 12y agoI have the impression the Kindle is heading in that direction. For example, sections other people have highlighted show up, practically as suggestions to do it yourself. For some reason this creeps me out, as reading is quite a personal thing, but it seems the attempt to turn it social and crowdsource data from it is happening.
- MereInterest 12y ago>At what point could this function be largely automated? At what point fully? Once we have strong AI capable of analyzing semantic content, determining which passages most strongly support the intended message, determining which unwritten passages could be written to more strongly support the intended message, determining the semantic linkings between different sections as the message is built up and optimizing the order of those sections. In other words, never.
- icebraining 12y agoWhat about freelance editors?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- onthedole 12y agoForbes has a good response piece to Krugman: http://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2014/10/20/paul-krugmans-error-over-amazons-market-power/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2014/10/20/paul-krug...
- MarkMc 12y agoI found the Forbes article unconvincing, especially this bit: > applying the same strictures to Standard Oil would have left that company alone rather than breaking it up. And that’s a conclusion that I’m entirely happy with too. So it would have been fine far Standard Oil to take over the entire US economy as long as it reduced prices far consumers?
- WalterBright 12y agoAs Rockefeller's biography "Titan" points out, Standard Oil's market share declined throughout the period of the anti-trust trial, and Rockefeller was unable to stem the slide.
- pron 12y agoThe main point isn't one action or another but, and Krugman says it clearly, that Amazon has too much power. Modern democracies usually strive to prevent concentration of power in few hands, especially if those hands aren't elected. The market, however, does often favor concentration of power, and when that happens, democracies should protect themselves. The US in particular has had a history of businesses gaining too much power and seriously hurting the public. This is Krugman's main point: [Y]es, I have Amazon Prime and use it a lot. But again, so what? The desirability of new technology, or even Amazon’s effective use of that technology, is not the issue. After all, John D. Rockefeller and his associates were pretty good at the oil business, too — but Standard Oil nonetheless had too much power, and public action to curb that power was essential... The robber baron era ended when we as a nation decided that some business tactics were out of line. And the question is whether we want to go back on that decision. Personally I think that exploitative practices by big business are making a huge comeback, in Silicon Valley in particular (see Google with privacy, Uber with workers, the SV non-poaching cartel and more). It is interesting to compare and contrast this with the Gilded Age robber barons. It's certainly not the same, but the robber barons are coming back, albeit in a new form.
- WalterBright 12y agoI read Rockefeller's biography "Titan" and could not find a single instance in it where Standard Oil's large market share "seriously hurt" the public. S.O. was a serious force in reducing the price of kerosene to the public - by 70%.
- pron 12y agoDid you skip the part where he (and his ilk) enslaved a large portion of the country in all but name? Or the part where the people begged government to help curb the robber barons, and Teddy Roosevelt wrestled power away from them?
- WalterBright 12y ago> he (and his ilk) enslaved a large portion of the country I read the book, and would be most interested in a cite for this. > the people begged government to help curb the robber barons, True, but that's not a statement the public was seriously harmed. > Teddy Roosevelt wrestled power away from them True, but also not a statement that the public was seriously harmed. It's possible that "Titan" is a whitewash, but it has 4.5 stars on Amazon and appears to be well regarded.
- rubinelli 12y agoIn many ways, publishing houses are to new authors what accelerators and VCs are to startups. They not only vet and fund them, they give guidance, access to contacts, and specialized help in areas like law and marketing. They pick riskier, less proven concepts, knowing that the hits will compensate for the busts. Well-known authors don't need publishing houses as much, but most of them would rather spend their time writing than publishing, and they know that their sales make it possible to bring in new faces.
- fpgeek 12y agoUnless you're talking about predatory VCs, comparing them to publishers is an insult. Publishers routinely demand that authors submit their next book (or even everything you write in the same genre for years) to them first and even if they reject it they have the right to match any offer you get later. How many VCs demand rights over your next N years of startups? Or we could talk about high-discount clauses: Where publishers get a bigger percentage when your books are discounted below a threshold they claim is unlikely... Only to turn around and encourage retailers (including Amazon) to discount your book just below that threshold - where they make more per book and you make substantially less. How often do VCs make more money by going behind your back to convince an acquirer to pay less? Or we could talk about rights reversion games, shuffling sales through shell companies cut royalties and on and on and on. I know VCs can be ruthless, underhanded and worse, but traditional publishers can make them look like kittens by comparison.
- JackC 12y agoTo reverse your point: unless you're talking about predatory publishers, comparing them to VCs is an insult. You can't get anywhere useful by excluding the bad actors in one industry and focusing solely on the bad actors in another industry.
- holdenk 12y agoI think its more that the industry standard among publishers is to demand the right of first refusal on additional books.
- AlexandrB 12y agoTalent discovery. Like in the music industry, where a few hits fund a lot of up-and-coming bands publishing has a few hits and many smaller authors that may or may not get big but need up-front funding to try. It's like VC for authors.
- naringas 12y agowhat if we replace Amazon with Walmart and publisher with manufacturers? "Walmart is squeezing manufacturers to push prices down, which is bad becuase... why?"
- skwirl 12y agoLower prices are good for consumers. If you manufacture commodities then ideally you will have no profit margin in a free market. If you did, someone could come in and undercut you and take your market share, without losing money doing so. Walmart is just being a rational consumer - if they can get something for cheaper somewhere else, they will. The only thing I have a problem with is when costs are cut by reducing wages to the point where employees have to take public assistance. This is government subsidization of your business. This should be solved with a mandatory minimum wage set to a value that is a living wage.
- logfromblammo 12y agoSome people would prefer to shop based on value or total quality rather than price. When minimizing price becomes the dominant merchant behavior, quality suffers. Yes, you can get a computer mouse shipped to your door in 2 days or less for $7. But you will also be replacing it in a few months when its cheap microswitch starts randomly double-clicking from a single button press. This, in itself is no big deal. You got what you paid for, basically. The danger is when other manufacturers, that formerly had more trustworthy brands, replace their microswitches with the cheaper part, without informing the customer that their build quality has been reduced. So you can also buy a $60 name-brand mouse that experiences exactly the same failure mode as the $7 item. Then value-based shoppers and cost-based shoppers end up buying exactly the same item, even though the former would dearly love to buy just one mouse that lasts for 10 years rather than 20 that last anywhere from 1 to 24 months each. Meanwhile, the quality-based shoppers have to pay higher prices for parts that are no longer available at scale. Or, as is more frequent, they take to the secondary market to buy goods manufactured before the cost-driven breakdown in overall quality. Aggressive cost controls are great for people who always buy the goods with the lowest up-front cost. But they absolutely suck for people who do not want to ensure things work by purchasing an ongoing subscription for replacement parts. I want my goods to be durable and reliable, not cheap enough to replace when it inevitably breaks.
- exelius 12y agoYeah; I agree. He would have a good argument except for the fact that the value of a single piece of content is declining across the board. That is fucking with a lot of established business models, specifically with the publishers. The value of a music album has decreased significantly because anyone can create one in their bedroom with free software and under $1000 worth of equipment. Same with a book - all you need is a laptop and you can self-publish either through e-books or on-demand publishing. Even video content - you can film entertainment content with your cell phone and distribute it on YouTube. It's a zero-sum game with entertainment, because the public only has so many hours in a day that they can spend consuming media content. So 30 minutes spent watching YouTube videos where the author makes MAYBE $0.05 per view means 5 minutes less to spend watching content with a higher value. Publishers will never go away for "premium" content: they do serve a marketing function where they can spread risk among a number of options. But their importance in a highly segmented market like book publishing is likely to decrease.
- WalterBright 12y agoI used to watch crummy shows on TV just because they were on and I was bored. Now, there is so much content available streaming online that there's no reason whatsoever to spend time watching anything less than the best.
- exelius 12y agoWell, most of the stuff online is pretty crummy too. But it's at least crummy stuff you've never seen as opposed to reruns.