3 ms·
What's missing in reddit/digg: a way to see which side won an argument in discussions
Although you can vote up/down individual comments, there's no easy way to see which side of an argument won overall.
Any ideas on how this could be done?
- ijoshua 19y agoEasy. The losers are usually the ones who participate.
- mynameishere 19y agoWrong. Plus: You just participated.
- Goladus 19y agoWell, he's right by virtue of a tautology. Winners are the ones who participate as well. Right or not, it's an asinine comment. I've downmodded maybe 3-4 posts in the past month and this was one of them.
- ijoshua 19y ago<q>You just participated.</q> I did not realize this was an argument. I guess I lost. Seriously, though, the most interesting arguments don't resolve for quite some time, if ever. For example, who was the winner in the infamous Torvalds v. Tanenbaum argument over monolithic versus micro-kernels? One could say that Torvalds "won," in the sense that Linux became far more successful than Minix. Yet, Windows and Mac OS are both based, in part, on a micro-kernel architecture, and both have a greater share of the market than Linux.
- ijoshua 19y agoI'd like to see a scoring system that evaluates the discussion or thread as a whole, rather than the individual contributions; a metric like a signal-to-noise ratio, where a thread gets a higher score for being on-topic and relevant, or a lower score for degenerating into a pissing match.
- run4yourlives 19y ago"Winning an argument is like winning at the Special Olympics. Sure you won, but you're still retarded."
- Goladus 19y agoThis comment is no more funny or insightful than it was 5 years ago. Worse, it discourages positive contributions as well as negative.
- nostrademons 19y agoPositive contributions usually don't spark arguments. Even if they're controversial or unpopular, they tend to spark discussion instead.
- Goladus 19y agoI disagree, and I also think the line between argument and discussion is rather blurry; especially in text-based communication. One of the most interesting threads I've read lately was that one where Walter Bright posted a comment about D in a thread bashing C++ programmers. His post was attacked by a few others, and the resulting argument was very interesting. I think this is the thread: http://kerneltrap.org/mailarchive/git/2007/9/7/257355 http://kerneltrap.org/mailarchive/git/2007/9/7/257355 Though I don't have time to find the specific chain of comments.
- euccastro 19y agoI think there is an inverse relationship between positive attitude and eagerness to win arguments.
- Goladus 19y agoThe point of an online discussion is not to win or lose, it's to learn and hopefully educate others.
- amichail 19y agoOnline discussions can go on forever. But if you keep score, one side might consider giving up if it is obvious that it is losing.
- s_baar 19y agoThat erroneously assumes that it is possible to win an argument on the internet.
- robg 19y agoPersonally, I think most online discussions are bankrupt. It's time to scrap the whole approach and start fresh. It's not close to how we share knowledge in the real world and simply stating and reading opinions is nothing more than good entertainment.
- cmars232 19y agoMaybe you should do this in a meta-site like Disqus, that'd be interesting. I could see why a site like Reddit/Digg wouldn't want to add a feature like this, it would probably encourage the wrong sort of behavior. But human nature is human nature, there's always going to be a market for a pissing contest, why not capture it? :D
- johnnygoodman 19y agoPerhaps comments could be tagged and any +1 or -1 to a comment would trickle down to all of those tags? Would people take the time to tag comments? You'd need a way to boil down the answer choices in order to declare a clear cut winner. By boiling it down, you take the personality and shades out gray out of the comment you'd be voting on and therefore much of the value. Also, if the winning side is a "pro life" tag and you are pro choice, you are unlikely to see much value or be swayed by the vote. I would see such a vote as dumbed down and dig into the comments for the 'real' content.
- inklesspen 19y agoIt can't be done. The truth doesn't become falsehood just because it gets voted down.
- deleted 19y ago[deleted]