3 ms·
I'm honored that you credit me with the authorship of the term sexism, but, unfortunately, I am not the originator of the concept. There is no sexism[pron] but
by pron 12y ago
I'm honored that you credit me with the authorship of the term sexism, but, unfortunately, I am not the originator of the concept. There is no sexism[pron] but simply "sexism"[1].
There is no rhetorical fallacy here, but the mere misuse of the term sexism by you, and it really doesn't matter how many people make that mistake. While you bring up murder and puppies as an example, you are simply mistaken in the meaning of the word sexism. You make an analogy to murder -- which implies intent -- while a more proper analogy is killing -- which does not. Killing is bad even if the deaths lack malice. Murder is worse than killing, but only when judgement is concerned. If killing is widespread (as sexism is), people care about stopping it more than passing judgement. The problem with sexism is, that unlike killing, those who are not its victims (and sometimes even its victims) are blind to it (although, to be sure, pointing out sexism often feels like judgment -- just as accusation in indirect killing does).
The articles you linked to are irrelevant -- when I say "sexism", I simply mean sexism (which I've even defined), while you insist on a wrong meaning of a word simply because you feel like it. There is little point in arguing about that.
> I do hope to prevent you from imposing your will on those women who behave in ways you disagree with.
Ah, this is where things become interesting, and because people here like their science fiction, let's talk sci-fi. Did the people living in the Matrix choose to live there or didn't know other possibilities existed? Was there liberation coerced or their subjugation, even though the former was quite inconvenience while the latter was as tranquil as slipping into a coma?
If society, over millennia, imbues people with an idea that benefits some and harms others, so much so that the oppressed can't see their oppression, isn't it the moral duty of those who can see outside the matrix to point it out, even if this entails some discomfort? How free is someones choice, if they've been raised to make it? You should know that even during slavery in the US, many slavery supporters claimed that at least some slaves liked their position in society -- which makes sense because they weren't exposed to a different reality.
Now, you should realize that this isn't rhetoric but quite the opposite. It is rhetoric that keeps most of us blind to reality. Once you start seeing how power structures in society work, that they ensure that the powerful stay in power -- even without any conscious, sinister conspiracy behind them, but a constant drip of ideas -- you'll feel like physicians must have felt when germs where discovered, and the true nature of many illnesses was finally truly seen.
The reason why feminism is so often concerned with words and rhetoric is precisely this. Being forced to actively thing about something so seemingly "natural" as language is a good mechanism of curing our blindness. If you live in the matrix, to see it you must question everything -- the more "innocuous" the better. It's so prevalent that it's hard to spot unless you try very hard.
[1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexism
- yummyfajitas 12y agoThe meaning of a word is defined by usage. You agreed my usage is common. If you look it up in the dictionary, you'll also find that it is in rough agreement with 3 separate and not fully compatible definitions. Sometimes the colloquial definition of a term does not disambiguate things sufficiently - this is a case of that. To provide a less politically charged example, is a "sound" "the sensation produced by stimulation of the organs of hearing" or "mechanical vibrations transmitted through an elastic medium"? The dictionary provides both of these definitions. It would be pointless to declare one definition "correct" and the other "wrong" if we were discussing a tree falling in the woods, since the important point is the underlying idea. We might call the first one sound[1], the second sound[2], and clearly use these two terms to understand reality: a tree falling in the woods with no one there to listen produces sound[2] but not sound[1]. This is the level of clarification I was seeking with my query. I'm not sure why you and dalke take such strong issue with it. Now, you should realize that this isn't rhetoric but quite the opposite. It is rhetoric that keeps most of us blind to reality...The reason why feminism is so often concerned with words and rhetoric is precisely this.* Then why are you arguing so strongly with me when I attempt to get past rhetoric and clarify the underlying concepts? Feminism wishes for multiple different phenomena to be described by the same label in order to help make reality clear?
- pron 12y ago> Feminism wishes for multiple different phenomena to be described by the same label in order to help make reality clear? No. The term "sexism" was first coined by feminists in the late sixties, and they defined its meaning to describe, well, sexism, rather than misogyny (the more overt, malicious, form of sexism, or the analogous to murder in your example), which is a far older word (misogyny appears in Webster's, while sexism doesn't). There's something else, though, that makes the accepted definition of sexism more "correct", or, at least, more useful, than your one (which is common, but isn't the common usage). Only the accepted definition of sexism describes how women are subjugated by society. Not misogyny, but a well established power structure, precipitated by many means, many of them innocent but certainly far from innocuous (same goes for racism, which is like sexism towards other races while xenophobia is analogous to misogyny). So, we already have a word for your definition, and personally I think that "ism" words are best used to describe social phenomena, or cultural ideas -- not individuals' actions (like murder) whose definition has to do with intent or judgment. "Your" sexism (which is really just misogyny) does not deserve an "ism" word, as it's more an act, or a "crime", than a cultural phenomenon. True, you are not the only one to use "sexism" colloquially to mean misogyny, but in this case, let's let the meaning of the word be that assigned to it by its inventors, at least while it's still young.