5 ms·
Absolutely horrified. > The Cobalt’s engine shut off and the lights inside and outside the car dimmed. Melton hit the brakes, but no power from the engine mean
by scotty79 12y ago
Absolutely horrified.
> The Cobalt’s engine shut off and the lights inside and outside the car dimmed. Melton hit the brakes, but no power from the engine meant no anti-lock brakes and no power steering.
I wasn't aware that anti-lock brakes (is that ABS?) is not a purely mechanical system. Also, was power steering hydraulic or electric? Shouldn't it be run of battery for short period of time?
> While Brooke’s lap belt glued her waist to the seat, her shoulder harness went slack the instant the engine shut off.
Now that's just criminally stupid.
EDIT: I guess I need to read through to the end to the article but that's a hard read for me for some reason.
- mirkules 12y agoABS is indeed the Anti-lock Braking System and I think it depends on sensors to determine the skidding amount and on software to determine the interval at which the brakes are applied and let go. So, the ABS is run off electricity and not a purely mechanical system. However, brakes themselves (without the "anti-lock" part) are purely mechanical/hydraulic, but since the brakes locked up, it didn't matter. I'm not entirely sure about electric power steering systems and how they work. ABS: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-lock_braking_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-lock_braking_system EPS: http://www.caranddriver.com/features/electric-vs-hydraulic-steering-a-comprehensive-comparison-test-feature http://www.caranddriver.com/features/electric-vs-hydraulic-s... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_power_steering https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_power_steering
- toomuchtodo 12y agoABS depends on power not only for wheel speed measurement, but also for power to drive the brake piston.
- bonestamp2 12y ago> I'm not entirely sure about electric power steering systems and how they work. It comes in a variety of forms, but it's usually an electric motor that adds torque as you turn the steering wheel to make it easier to turn.
- mirkules 12y agoIn a hydraulic power steering system, if the power is cut, the driver can still turn the wheel (although it's much harder to do). In an EPS, is this still true?
- lmm 12y ago> Also, was power steering hydraulic or electric? Shouldn't it be run of battery for short period of time? Further down the article it answers this; yes, if the engine had simply "died" the power steering would still have run off the battery. But because the ignition was turned off, all the power was cut off.
- Too 12y agoCutting all the power based on only the key must be the most stupid thing I've heard today, especially power steering?! Really, I've worked in automotive and all designs I've seen keep important components alive as long as the vehicle is moving, regardless of key position. THAT is the design flaw here, not that the key is too easy to twist. This can be quite a hot topic, I frequently see people wanting the key as a "last line of defense against electronics and programming error switch" and i can understand that concern and sometimes think that way myself but really, if they are not confident enough in their system and think they require a human controllable "main switch" they might as well put a big red emergency shutdown button in the middle of the dashboard, i wonder how many people would buy such a car.
- Perdition 12y agoThe point is key switches as cut offs work fine when the component doesn't have major faults. Any other electrical control system could cause just as many issues if designed poorly. Imagine if GM was just as sloppy with a push-to-start electronically controlled system that could shutdown due to EMF. And there have actually been issues with push-to-start systems. One model I can remember required the user to hold down the button to shut off power in an emergency, when the most common user reaction was to rapidly jab the button.
- fnordfnordfnord 12y ago>The point is key switches as cut offs work fine when the component doesn't have major faults. GP is correct. Cutting the electrical power to the power steering assist while the car is in motion is a design flaw. Can you think of any reason why the car should not have operational power steering when it is in motion[1]? [1] If you thought "for towing", that situation can be handled by the tow truck operator manually disabling the steering.
- Animats 12y agoThat's not quite right. The Cobalt, like a lot of cars, has a seat-belt pre-tensioner. This is an explosive device that pulls in the seat belt by about 4 inches when the air bags fire. The seat belt's basic inertial locking function still works without power. Anti-lock brakes, on the other hand, definitely require power. They're computer-controlled, using pulse counters in the wheels, electrically-controlled brake valves, and rate gyros. With ABS, jamming on the brakes is just fine. Without ABS, jamming on the brakes is awful. In the first crash mentioned, the driver not only jammed on the brakes, but having entered the skid, turned away from the skid, which makes it worse. It was also a side crash, so the air bags would not have fired. Who practices non-ABS skid recoveries in cars any more? Losing electrical power in that car is a big deal. You lose propulsion, power steering, power brakes, anti-skid braking, seat belt pre-tensioning, and air bags all at once. That's bad design. All those electrical functions should be enabled until the transmission is in PARK.
- x0x0 12y agoAnd the airbags wouldn't go off, either, without the key turned on. But having your car suddenly go from having abs -- where jamming the pedal down is probably the right thing to do -- to a state where the driver must pump the pedal is probably more than virtually all drivers can handle.
- emp_zealoth 12y agoGiven my experiences i personally feel she has shown terrible lack of skill - why slam on the brakes? The car was fully controllable. I`ve had my engine stall once and i mistakenly turned my engine off (and the hydraulic power steering went off) midturn and it wasn't a light car. I was completely fine. On the other hand i find american buisness practices despicable and sickening.
- msl 12y ago> why slam on the brakes? Maybe she wanted to stop the car she had lost control of? The reason for ABS to exist is that slamming the brakes is a very natural thing for (most of) us to do in a dangerous situation. If you're designing a car for a human to drive, you should keep this in mind.