3 ms·
Suppose the author had followed the advice she kept receiving from everyone she talked to with experience dealing with book bloggers, and ignored the blathering
by tzs 12y ago
Suppose the author had followed the advice she kept receiving from everyone she talked to with experience dealing with book bloggers, and ignored the blathering of the bloggers.
Would would be the likely consequences for the author and her book?
The book's Amazon reviews are fine. The critical reviews there generally seem to be sane and rational, not trollish. As far as I can tell Googling a bit, the intense negativity seems confined to Goodreads and maybe some blogs. Taking a look at a few of the negative Goodreads reviews, it is pretty obvious that they are not legitimate [1] reviews. Most people reading the Goodreads reviews to actually try to determine if they would enjoy the book should have little trouble recognize the troll reviews and ignoring them.
In short, do these people actually matter?
[1] What I mean by "legitimate" is that the reviewer read the book, and is giving their honest opinion of the book itself based upon just its contents.
- lgas 12y agoSomeone who's reading through the reviews might be able to figure out which are troll reviews and ignore them, but someone searching through a list sorted by rating or just visually scanning a list with star ratings surely won't, and thus may never make it to the actual reviews to realize there are trolls present.