4 ms·
Completely agree. The tech community (including most HN readers) seems to be too closed minded about this subject. Encryption like this is a drastic change in
by slg 12y ago
Completely agree. The tech community (including most HN readers) seems to be too closed minded about this subject. Encryption like this is a drastic change in the legal landscape. It means that our property goes from 4th amendment protections to 5th amendment protections. Whether you think that is a good idea is a matter of your own personal politics, but that change can't be easily dismissed.
Could you imagine if there was some new lock technology that came along that forced everyone to abide by vampire rules. This lock would required police to obtain your express invitation to enter your home regardless of whether they had a warrant or not. Now imagine the uproar that would cause. That is exactly what this type of technology does for our phone.
- Zigurd 12y agoAutomatic document destruction devices have been around forever without causing a crisis.
- opendais 12y agoEffectively unbreakable encryption [for the statute of limitations length of time] has been around for decades. This just means it easier.
- AnthonyMouse 12y ago> Encryption like this is a drastic change in the legal landscape. It isn't a change at all. You have been able to anonymously rent a locker at a YMCA or a self-storage unit or a cabin in the woods since forever. Evidence of a crime stored there is inaccessible to law enforcement because they don't know where it is. There is no practical difference between "don't know where it is" and "don't have the password." This is not a new thing.
- wfunction 12y ago> There is no practical difference between "don't know where it is" and "don't have the password." I think you forget you're living in the real world. There is also no practical difference between accidental and intentional murder, so by your logic we should treat those the same way too.
- amirmc 12y agoD'you think such locks (fortresses?) don't already exist?