3 ms·
>The philosophy of time is one of the remaining bulwarks of a philosophical position called 'dualism', which holds that minds are completely separate from our b
by trhway 12y ago
>The philosophy of time is one of the remaining bulwarks of a philosophical position called 'dualism', which holds that minds are completely separate from our bodies
Whose mind? Would you say that the mind of a worm is separate from its body? Suppose - no. Then where does mind gets separates from the body - at ant level? at fish level? at lizard? at mammal? at ape? at Neanderthal? at Cro-Magnon 20K years ago?
Mind is just an emergent behavior of a pretty complex organized matter. The more complex the matter the more its ability to increase entropy beyond simple local gradient and that ability is what we call mind.
"Free will" is just a part of that "mind". The obvious question here again - does a worm has free will?
In general these notions of separate mind or especially soul are misconceptions coming from religion where world was created 6 thousands years ago with God giving soul to humans only and with no continuous biological connection between first living cells couple billion years ago and humans today.
- jquery 12y agoThese "misconceptions" don't come from religion. That's a huge strawman, as if you have to believe in a Great Flood to be curious about the nature of consciousness, beyond declaring it a property of entropy as if that answers anything at all.
- Retric 12y agoVideo game enemies have a "Mind" they can make predictions, plan, and with reasonable levels of AI even learn. But, we understand what's going on which "Kills" any meaningful debate. Not really understaniding cellular biology and the emergent behavior of the human brain is no reason to assume anything odd is going on either. PS: Ok, there is a reasonable question of how good an AI needs to be before killing it is wrong.
- Natsu 12y agoSo if you were programmed to say this, where and how did the original program originate?
- Retric 12y agoThat's not an answerable question. Making it meaningless. Which electron in you left ear had the lowest energy over the last second? PS: This is actually a trick question as the frame of reference is important.
- Natsu 12y agoI do not agree at all. I think that there must be one (or a few) simplest possible computing systems and that it would be both informational and interesting to figure out the basis upon which biological computing is premised.
- Retric 12y agoThere are lot's of simple computing systems, knowing about them tells you nothing about biological computing. (ED: Sort of, there are classes of computing systems and understanding their limitations has some value.) If for no other reason than the fact you can generally simulate X computing system in Y and Y computing system in X. Let's take a step back and look at flight a much 'simpler' system that we 'know' a lot about. First we looked at birds and insects and thought this is possible. You can get a fairly simple model of how wings work that's good enough to build a basic glider. It's wrong, a much better approximation let's you build high efficiency sub sonic jet's. Crossing the sound barrier demonstrates flaws, but we have yet more models for that. A particle model of an aircraft based on Newtonian physics is even better and avoids those wacky approximations. Unfortunately it's way to complex to use and even worse Newtonian physics is also wrong. QM is better still, but also wrong. A mix of QM and General relativity is the best we have, but again it's wrong. Where was I going with that line of thinking? We might be lucky enough to find a model that's indistinguishable from reality. That does not mean it's useful or even correct. And just because we build something that thinks (fly's) that does not mean it's got much to do with how we think (or birds fly). PS: This might all seem pedantic. But, asking how something works is not an answerable question. Asking for a model of how something works is. But, useful model's often have little to do with reality. (ex: epicycles can approximate any curved orbit to any precision given enough of them. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deferent_and_epicycle http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deferent_and_epicycle They where effectively taking a Fourier transform of the orbits.)
- gottebp 12y agoAt the full blown materialist end there's another big problem though: Are you just a cloud of ever changing atoms mistaken for a person? Since almost none of the atoms from your childhood remain in you now, are you actually the same individual? If yes, by what measure and means? If no, then how can a cloud of atoms have things like "rights", personhood, etc? In addition to both dualism and materialism there is a third way called Hylomorphism: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hylomorphism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hylomorphism
- trhway 12y ago>Since almost none of the atoms from your childhood remain in you now, are you actually the same individual? i hoped that not, i hope that i did mature at least a bit :) But you question i suppose was about a little bit different aspect of "the same" and to that aspect i'll ask you - this river, the set of ever changing atoms of water, is it the same river that it was a second ago, an hour, an year...? >If no, then how can a cloud of atoms have things like "rights", personhood, etc? In physics where is no "rights". The "rights" is just a "mind" construct reflecting current balance of violent interactions between different "clouds of ever changing atoms".
- MichaelGG 12y agoI don't think these questions are really very interesting. "When is a day no longer sunny, but cloudy?" There is probably a name for this class of things, where there's some fuzzy-ish boundary. But it seems like s mistake to get caught up in it as if it makes a difference. Sorta like arguing over what life is. Is a plant alive? But plants aren't like animals, so what then? It actually seems like arguing about definitions.
- JacksonGariety 12y agoI urge you to re-read the post you're replying to, since it's actually a lot more complicated than you think. - There's nothing even ~close~ to neurobiological evidence for subjective experience - Nothing has changed in 6 thousand years, we know as much about god, time, and subjectivity as we do today You ~think~ that dualism is impossible but you don't understand monism.