5 ms·
it is really a concept for revoking others' right to free speech Yes, because in Europe free speech isn't an absolute right; sometimes the right of privacy tru
by wmf 12y ago
it is really a concept for revoking others' right to free speech
Yes, because in Europe free speech isn't an absolute right; sometimes the right of privacy trumps free speech.
- adharmad 12y agoAnything that trumps free speech, except for the truly extreme cases (shouting fire in a theatre etc.) is a slippery slope that can erode liberty over a period of time. How long before this moves into "right to not be offended trumps free speech" territory?
- anon1385 12y agoSo you are saying that the exceptions to free speech that you agree with are fine, but that the exceptions other people/cultures have chosen and that you disagree with are a 'slippery slope'.
- Karunamon 12y agoThis standard of yours completely eliminates the ability to critically comment on the actions of "other cultures".
- fidotron 12y agoNot at all. You can comment all you want about it, but it doesn't compel them to change how they are at all.
- Karunamon 12y agoThen why call it out as if it were a negative? Nothing anybody says on Hacker News is going to change EU law.
- fidotron 12y agoBecause you're exhibiting cultural imperialism.
- Karunamon 12y agoWhat does that even mean? You're talking out of both sides of your mouth here. First it's okay to comment on other culture's behaviors and now it's "cultural imperialism". How about everyone is okay to comment on whatever they wish without the meta value judgements? I think that system works pretty well.
- DanBC 12y agoThere is a tendency for some US commentators to totally ignore the European attitude around freedom of speech and to talk about the slippery slope to totalitarian states. Sometimes those people will mix up "first ammendment" rights with what a website owner is allowed to do; or they appear to be unaware of the very many cases of people in America who lose their jobs or are arrested because they wear the wrong t-shirt or have an innocent poster on their door. We often hear these people when there's coverage of twitter trolls going to court. They'll say that it's ridiculous to prosecute people for being mean on twitter. This is intensely frustrating because -and this should be fucking obvious- no-one is arrested for being a bit mean on social media. People are arrested for making credible repeated threats of violence. But that happens in the US.
- mineshaftgap 12y agoAn Englishman did three months for an offensive drunken tweet after a match, brilliant.
- pionar 12y ago>or they appear to be unaware of the very many cases of people in America who lose their jobs or are arrested because they wear the wrong t-shirt or have an innocent poster on their door. Arrested and convicted of a crime are two different things. Do you have any evidence of that happening? I know of a Virginia teenager who was arrested last year because he wouldn't take off an NRA shirt, but first, he wasn't arrested for the shirt, he was arrested for obstruction, and second, charges were dropped. As for European attitudes toward free speech, I don't say they're wrong for Europeans, I just think some of them are daft, like locking people up for racist remarks or offensive speech. That just turns harmless idiots into martyrs.
- mpyne 12y agoYou say that as if it's hypocritical, but this seems like an almost axiomatic statement to me. It is perfectly reasonable to have opinions about exceptions to free speech which are safe and unsafe, and to advocate why to those with different opinions. Just like the USA's interpretation of "free speech" isn't sacred for the rest of the world (and might actually be wrong!), a European nation's interpretation of safe and unsafe free speech is not absolute and might be wrong. Portions of the U.S. used to have a strong cultural affinity for human slavery, yet many within that same U.S. argued that slavery was wrong from day 1 of the current republic. Europe used to have a cultural affinity for anti-Semitism (and it hasn't completely gone away). If you believe in any sort of objective truth whatsoever, then it's possible for a 'cultural value' to still be wrong.
- jasonzemos 12y agoShouting fire in a theater isn't an extreme case if you think about it. When was the last time you heard of a stampede in a crowded theater when someone shouted fire and there was none? I've never heard of it. Who would take off running? Would you take off running because someone else is? Honestly. The case this phrase originated from is overpraised.
- mc32 12y agoBasically, one can imagine, one would not want someone to invoke panic into others frivolously when it has potential to cause physical harm. Another example would be shouting "She's got a gun, arhhhh!" in a crowded plazza while setting off some firecrackers.
- Crito 12y agoThe case the phrase is from was about placing limitations on blatantly political speech. It was a truly reprehensible decision. "A unanimous Supreme Court, in a famous opinion by Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr., concluded that defendants who distributed leaflets to draft-age men, urging resistance to induction, could be convicted of an attempt to obstruct the draft, a criminal offense." -- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schenck_v._United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schenck_v._United_States From it's very inception, that phrase has been used to justify the restriction of political speech. Nothing has changed since 1917, people still use it to argue against political speech to this day.
- mineshaftgap 12y ago> How long before this moves into "right to not be offended trumps free speech" territory? This is already the case in Europe.
- stretchwithme 12y agoThen why isn't the government going on to BBC servers and removing those articles? Don't they violate somebody's privacy? Is there even a right to keep private something everybody knows? A right to have milk on the floor be in the glass it spilled out of? Free speech wasn't an absolute right in Soviet Russia either. And, yes, they too had ways of avoiding naming what they were actually doing.
- untog 12y agoIs there an equivalent of Godwin's Law for invoking Soviet Russia when discussing free speech? The answer to your question is that the EU law is written horribly, by people who have no real idea how the internet works.
- xtrumanx 12y agoI hope not. I already find it annoying enough when people decide to shut down a conversation by bringing up Godwin's Law.
- elif 12y agoIn the US it is not an absolute right either. Ignoring the cliche fire in a theater thing, the ag-gag bills and provisions of the patriot act make it illegal to say something which could impact the profitability of perishable food production chains. Even true statements are illegal to make.
- dkfmn 12y agoBut many would argue that these laws are unconstitutional. Free speech is one of the highest laws in the land and there's a court challenge underway: https://www.aclu.org/free-speech/aclu-idaho-and-coalition-files-lawsuit-over-controversial-ag-gag-law https://www.aclu.org/free-speech/aclu-idaho-and-coalition-fi...
- mpyne 12y agoAs the other comment mentions, restrictions like those may well be overturned, but it's true that free speech is not an absolute right within the U.S., considering we have laws against slander, libel, divulging personally-identifiable information and some types of medical records, espionage, etc. Free speech is an individual right that like any other right, gets balanced against others' individual rights.