2 ms·
We already see the pernicious effect of eviscerating all the meaning from words like "limited" in copyright and patent law. If you take the literal, almost math
by Zigurd 12y ago
We already see the pernicious effect of eviscerating all the meaning from words like "limited" in copyright and patent law. If you take the literal, almost mathematical, meaning of "limited" it places no practical limits on anything. Limited now means the opposite. That's obviously a ridiculous and evil outcome.
Similarly the words "necessary and proper" have lost any power because lawyers have argued them into submission.
The role of judges should be not to improvise on the basis of this evacuation of meaning, but to assign a reasonable meaning, based at least in part on supporting documents that show what the authors of those words had in mind.