2 ms·
We've had copyright for over two hundred years, so we can judge the difference between before and after. In any artistic field (music, painting, literature, sc
by bambax 12y ago
We've had copyright for over two hundred years, so we can judge the difference between before and after.
In any artistic field (music, painting, literature, sculpture...) the best works were produced before copyright existed.
The best and most interesting output of the human mind since 1790 were not in the arts but in the hard sciences, outside of the realm of copyright.
It's understandable that "copyright holders" would fight hard to maintain the status quo or even extend protections indefinitely; what I find baffling, and truly depressing, is that everyone else lets it happen.
- thisishugo 12y ago> The best and most interesting output of the human mind since > 1790 were not in the arts but in the hard sciences, outside > of the realm of copyright. This is the most utterly ridiculous claim I have heard in a long time, not least because what constitutes "the best works" of art is entirely subjective.
- bambax 12y agoIt can't be both subjective and ridiculous. If it's subjective then I'm right for the reason that I'm judge and jury. If it's not then I can be wrong, but you have to make an argument for it, based on some objective criteria.
- thisishugo 12y agoAn opinion isn't right or wrong, it just is, no matter how strongly you assert it. And it certainly is open to ridicule: would you take seriously someone claiming, with absolute sincerity, to be the sovereign ruler of the Gumdrop Kingdom?