2 ms·
> I don't quite get the point of discussing or arguing about what the framers "meant". It's pretty important to one extremely common justification for the gove
by baddox 12y ago
> I don't quite get the point of discussing or arguing about what the framers "meant".
It's pretty important to one extremely common justification for the government's authority, that being the "social contract." As the justification goes, the reason that authority is legitimate is that we have agreed to it. When you point out that, no, in fact no living person has agreed to any such thing or even been given the opportunity to do so, the response is that people in the past agreed explicitly to the Constitution, via their elected representatives in each state that ratified it.
If you accept this justification (you can probably tell by my tone that I don't), it ought to be pretty important what was agreed to, and the only remotely plausible way to interpret the terms of a supposed contract is as the parties to the contract intended.