13 ms·
People should be able to install whatever software on their computers they want. "What if so-and-so grabs such-and-such's phone and installs it?" Well, the same
by moron4hire 12y ago
People should be able to install whatever software on their computers they want. "What if so-and-so grabs such-and-such's phone and installs it?" Well, the same thing applies to my PC. A lot of opsec goes out the window with physical access. Put a passcode on your phone.
- userbinator 12y agoPeople should be able to install whatever software on their computers they want. I absolutely agree, but Apple and Google certainly don't (and Microsoft appears to be joining them.) They'll all claim that the reason they're restraining you is "for your safety", which is easily accepted by most consumers but not the ones who value freedom more. Sadly, the latter category appears to be a gradually decreasing minority.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> People should be able to install whatever software on their computers they want. And Android supports sideloading apps. OTOH, that doesn't obligate Google Play to allow any software you want to sell into their store, especially when it violates black and white terms associated with the use of the store.
- moron4hire 12y agoI don't so much have a problem with the Play store culling out certain violating apps. I'd just prefer it that they do an honest, real job of it[0]. Either curate the system or make it open. What we have now are non-open systems that are not actually all that curated. [0] And that's slightly separate from whether or not non-app store programs are installable. But I do think that Apple and Google have explicitly attempted to discourage and obfuscate any process for doing so, even so far as to call into question who truly owns the device, you or the corporation.
- declan 12y ago> People should be able to install whatever software on their computers they want Yep, agreed. But unless I'm missing something, Google is not preventing you from installing whatever apps you want on your handheld computer. <tahooie>, the fellow who started this thread, is free to distribute the .apk file for his app via his own site. (Apple, on the other hand, forbids it.) In fact, Google tells you how to do this: "you can make them available for download on your own website or server... An easy and quick way to release your apps is to send them to users by email... you can distribute your apps through any app marketplace you want or use multiple marketplaces..." http://developer.android.com/distribute/tools/open-distribution.html http://developer.android.com/distribute/tools/open-distribut... And when I've been working on Recent.io, it's a lot easier to distribute to early testers on Android vs. iOS. Simply add someone to a Google Group/G+ group vs. TestFlight, must open in Mail app, provisioning profiles, recompiling, re-uploading, why doesn't this version work, I hit my 100-user limit, etc. Ick. If the Google Play Store's policies become too aggressive, app developers will begin to shift to competing stores or distribute directly or find HTML5 workarounds. Of course I agree that Google should have reasonable policies, but if you don't like them, they (unlike Apple) at least give you alternatives.