8 ms·
The Mormon Church Is Building a Family Tree of the Entire Human Race
- tokenadult 12y agoThe correction at the bottom of the article doesn't inspire confidence in the author's fact-checking. I wonder what an expert reviewer would think of the rest of the book. The last book I encountered with such a broad theme about human genetics was panned by all expert reviewers.
- lukeholder 12y agoThe LDS church is doing massive amounts of work in preserving historical records. Here is a cool video about the process https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OFPo5BSS_AA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OFPo5BSS_AA
- akbar501 12y ago> The LDS church is doing massive amounts of work in preserving historical records. Definitely. I think this is an area where LDS could do better PR.
- djloche 12y agoThe preservation of and digitization of records is probably more important than the family tree project. So many records are completely lost/destroyed during wars over the years, hopefully having proper copies/backups made during this relative lull will prove effective.
- thret 12y agoIt all sounds good until you get to the part where they don't include same sex couples. This is why a non-religious entity should oversee the project. I imagine a family tree for our entire species that also included DNA would be medically quite useful. Some day, perhaps.
- CaveTech 12y agoSerious question: Do same sex couples really contribute to the worlds family tree? Technically their gene pool ends when that decision is made.
- aaronbrethorst 12y agoSure. See http://itsconceivablenow.com/surrogacy/ http://itsconceivablenow.com/surrogacy/ and https://www.pacrepro.com https://www.pacrepro.com for two random selections made from 20 seconds consulting Google.
- wwweston 12y agoOne could make a distinction between parenting and parentage, and under such a distinction there's not really any such thing as same-sex parentage yet. (And this distinction is completely orthogonal to the question of whether same-sex couples get the right to be legally recognized as a couple or parents.) I imagine that over time, any purported complete genealogy will make those distinctions but come to include information about both.
- akbar501 12y ago> One could make a distinction between parenting and parentage, and under such a distinction there's not really any such thing as same-sex parentage yet. While both people in a same sex couple cannot claim parentage on the same child, one parent can. With multiple children each partner could claim parentage on one child, but not the other. This is not different than a 2nd marriage where each hetero partner can claim parentage on only 1 child.
- vidarh 12y agoBut in genealogy, you would not tend to want to record the person as a child of both of them, but to record the birth parents. In fact, in many instances you would not model "birth of couple X" but "person A and person B were married between years ...", "person C has father B and mother D". Exactly because re-marriages and adultery, and children born out of wedlock has always been common (and known), so even if dealing with same sex couples is a reasonably new thing, dealing with children where linking their parentage to a specific couple is nothing new. Of course, the practice of lying about family history is equally old, so in practice most genealogy becomes unreliable very quickly. In my own family tree, we have a child who in official registers is listed as having a mother we have lots of further data on, and the father is listed as a "Friedrich Denneche, travelling hat-maker from Bremen". Problem is at the time (early 1800's I think), everyone had to register with local police when entering Oslo, and there is no record of any travelling hat-maker from Bremen. Nor did my dad find any records in Germany (though it's possible that there would be guild-records he did not find, he never got a chance to spend much time looking at German records) that matched. His theory, which of course can't be proven, was that the real dad was the mothers brother-in-law. Especially as he took her in and later adopted the child and she lived with him and his wife (talk about awkward situation if my dads theory is true...). But at the time this happened, sexual relations between in-laws was legally considered incest in Norway, and it was a crime not to list the father on the birth certificate, and a crime to lie on it, so if the theory is true she was in a bind: she had to put down a father, but could not put down the real father without even worse problems, and could not put down someone who might find out and object. Inventing a person nobody would expect to be able to find would have been a safe way out.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- austenallred 12y agoFor those that are curious, here is an image of the vault the article refers to, taken by my uncle earlier today: http://imgur.com/w6Jqku4 http://imgur.com/w6Jqku4 As you can see, it's currently under construction. The vault was created to withstand earthquakes, nuclear strikes, and various other sorts of natural disasters. My uncle works for a company that creates archives of newspapers and licenses them to libraries, universities, etc. They had purchased the rights to millions of newspapers dating back to the civil war, but lacked the manpower to convert all of the microfiche into digital copies, and in turn have those digital copies indexed. The Mormon Church provides a massive labor force of people who are now digitizing the content for free, simultaneously making those records available to the public who hold subscriptions to that particular service and making them available for free to members of the Mormon Church. Through deals like this and over hundreds of years the Church has built the most impressive family history library known to mankind. As a Mormon, I was required to know and research family history growing up, and am encouraged frequently to do so now. I just finished beta testing an iOS app called "family search" that the Church is building, allowing anyone to add pictures, video, stories, etc. of their ancestors. In doing so you run into people you are related to who are doing the same work, and learn thing about your roots you never would have known. It's fascinating, though I'm by no means a family history buff.
- IvyMike 12y agoSomeone here probably knows, but two questions immediately spring to mind. 1) Was there any bowdlerization of the records--any attempt to cover up scandalous lineages that are or were at one time against Mormon norms? (For example, interracial relationships prior to 1978) 2) Are they able to handle cyclical family trees, such as described in this famous stack overflow question: http://stackoverflow.com/q/6163683/67591 http://stackoverflow.com/q/6163683/67591
- bostik 12y ago> Are they able to handle cyclical family trees Heh, this reminds me of an assignment in a Finnish university. A second-year programming course requires to build a family tree parser with the appropriate data structure design. The tests are automated: students upload their sources through a web form, the backend builds the code and feeds it a number of test cases. The trick is that the inputs are not provided ahead of time. Once a test set fails, the student is provided with the input(s) that broke their submission. A student can submit their code at most four times, and a failure to pass the tests also means a failed course. One of the inputs is the family tree of the Egyptian Pharaohs.
- rmc 12y ago2) Are they able to handle cyclical family trees, such as described in this famous stack overflow question: http://stackoverflow.com/q/6163683/67591* http://stackoverflow.com/q/6163683/67591* Their current software spec for GEDCOM can't even handle same-sex marriage. GEDCOM is rapidly becoming a poor choice for reflecting current reality.
- spindritf 12y agoIt's discussed below[1]. AFAIK people of the same sex cannot have a biological descendant of both so it's inconsequential here. A more pertinent complaint is the one you cut out: incest. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8469570 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8469570
- rmc 12y ago
- kristopolous 12y agoI am really curious if they are going to try to bridge the biblical narrative to the historical record somehow. I imagine a lot of acrobatics would have to be done to tie the two together ... since um, you know ...
- tfinniga 12y agoYeah, all that's been done for a long time, way before the Mormons. I think it's mostly been done by eager genealogists paid by rich noblemen and kings to trace their lineage back to Adam. If you can find your relationship to royalty, then you can usually find a path back to Adam.
- joshdance 12y agoPeople try to bridge the narratives all the time. The Church doesn't try to, the just provide as many records as they can. I was exploring the FamilySearch.org site one day and kept going as far back as I could. I got to Adam which means that someone had linked everything back. A lot of time individuals will find themselves on a royal line which goes back pretty far, and then jump to the Bible somehow. And it seems like everything goes thru Charlemagne. :)
- rmc 12y agoI doubt it'd be a problem. Human records don't go back that far. Even presuming a "earth is 6000 years old" case, I don't think there are many records from back then.
- 72deluxe 12y agoInteresting. Did you know that the Mormons baptise people multiple times in the name of dead people? It's based on a misinterpretation of 1 Cor 15:29 I believe (that verse is referring to being spiritually dead). They buy up records of dead people and baptise new members multiple times using the names of the people on the registers. I often wonder if this contributes to the count of members? Can anyone enlighten me?
- vidarh 12y agoThe reason for this is that they believe that only those who are baptised goes to heaven. But at the same time, they believe that you can effectively baptise your ancestors this way, and that if said ancestors soul accepts the baptism, that's a route to heaven. So it's not "baptising new members multiple times". It is baptising new members and their ancestors, with the member being a "stand in". They still only have one new member - they obviously have no way of knowing if the ancestors accepted the baptism, and either way they're still dead. Genealogy basically becomes a route to saving the souls of your ancestors.
- tfinniga 12y ago> I often wonder if this contributes to the count of members? Can anyone enlighten me? No, the baptisms for the dead are not included in the count of members. You have to be living and baptised to be counted, and either die or formally request name removal to be removed. As far as inaccuracy goes, there are lots of people who don't attend and many who don't self-identify as Mormon counted in the membership rolls. I'd guess active mormons are probably somewhere between 1/4 to 1/2 of what's reported.
- 72deluxe 12y agoAh OK thanks.
- ljoshua 12y agoSince the membership count was already answered (no, membership count is based strictly on those living), I'll offer a quick comment on the other half of your question. From a scriptural sense, the practice is actually based on the concept of modern revelation, where we believe that God has revealed the practice and how it works through modern-day prophets, as was done in the past. The Corinthians scripture ("misinterpretation" is rather open to interpretation) is used simply to point out an instance where it was probably practiced in the churches at the time of Paul.
- 1ris 12y agoAnd now just image a world where these records where forgotten or never created: The holocaust could not have happened. I really don't like collection of data, and especially not this kind of data.