3 ms·
I'm not talking about how people respond. I'm talking about whether we consider the responses to be accurate. Usually, the implication is that people are overes
by baddox 12y ago
I'm not talking about how people respond. I'm talking about whether we consider the responses to be accurate. Usually, the implication is that people are overestimating their own merit.
- pessimizer 12y agoIt sounds as if you're talking about the difference between the average or the median. The prisoners were asked about the average unjailed person, and the findings are from the average response. There might be more data that asked prisoners to say if they are better than most people, and from the data collected, I'm sure that you could determine if most prisoners thought they were better than the average person. As it is, I'm assuming that prisoners answered from a list of characteristics about themselves, average prisoners, and average unjailed people on some linear scale.
- baddox 12y ago> It sounds as if you're talking about the difference between the average or the median. It's more subtle than that. Both average and median refer to a number, so you have to decide how to turn "driving ability" or "moralness" into a number. Two ways of doing that are to simply sort all people, and then use their ordinal as the number. In that case, average and median would be the same. Another way is to actually assign a meaningful number to each person, but there's not an obvious way to do that. You could choose an arbitrary proxy stat, like how many traffic accidents you've been in or how many people you've murdered, but then you're going to end up with a massively uneven distribution such that a large majority of people are tied for "the best" and thus the majority of people can accurately say they are above average.