3 ms·
> A popular example is the finding that most drivers think they are a better-than-average driver. The explanation in the article (that most people really are g
by bambax 12y ago
> A popular example is the finding that most drivers think they are a better-than-average driver.
The explanation in the article (that most people really are good drivers and that the average is drawn "low" because of very bad drivers) is flat-out wrong.
The correct explanation is described in detail in Daniel Kahneman' Thinking, Fast and Slow. It's impossible to assess our own position on the grand scale of driving ability; when the brain gets asked a difficult question, it quietly changes the question to a similar one, much easier to answer.
So when people are asked "are you a better-than-average driver", since they have no idea what the average is (or what the average means) they answer instead the question "am I an okay driver" and answer "yes".
This is probably what happens with prisoners too (or, they're actually kinder than the average people they know, and that's why they got caught).
- evincarofautumn 12y agoHow do we know this has anything to do with self-perception? Negative feelings tend to be given more weight—a bad review of a restaurant is much more likely to make you avoid it than a good review is to make you visit it—so people could simply believe that “the average person” is worse (at driving, being honest, &c.) than the true average. If I see several traffic accidents a year, I note that since I haven’t had one, I must be doing better than the nebulous category of “other drivers”. After all, the probability of someone else’s having an accident this year is scrillions of times higher than the probability of my having one, even if every individual driver is about as good as me.
- S_A_P 12y agoUpvote just for mentioning this book! I purchased, started reading and have subsequently forgotten to finish this book after work got in the way.
- bambax 12y agoOh read it, read it, it's fantastic.
- baddox 12y agoI can't speak to how everyone interprets the question, and I don't know if you have actual data on how people interpret the question (you mention that book, but I haven't read it). I can tell you that I consider myself to be a better than average driver because I have never been in an accident (as a driver) or received any traffic infractions, which is the interpretation you call "flat-out wrong." If I had been in an accident or received a traffic infraction, then I would have to actually consult data to determine whether I am above or below average. Until then, I think I have a very reasonable claim to being above average.
- ripter 12y agoI think your response just proved his point. We have no idea what 'average' means, so the mind tries to find something it does know. Like never being in an accident and not receiving traffic infractions. According to this: http://www.statisticbrain.com/driving-citation-statistics/ http://www.statisticbrain.com/driving-citation-statistics/ only 20% of drivers get traffic infractions, meaning the average driver has never had one.
- baddox 12y ago> We have no idea what 'average' means, so the mind tries to find something it does know. It's more like we have to interpret what "average" means in this context. It's not "making up something that isn't an average," it's "deciding what quantity to average." > According to this: http://www.statisticbrain.com/driving-citation-statistics/ http://www.statisticbrain.com/driving-citation-statistics/ only 20% of drivers get traffic infractions, meaning the average driver has never had one. The average number of infractions per driver is greater than zero. That means that I am better than average. It also means that at least 80% of drivers are better than average.
- Shish2k 12y ago> only 20% of drivers get traffic infractions, meaning the average driver has never had one. The median driver has never had one, but the mean (which is what most people mean by average) has had >=0.2