9 ms·
> A popular example is the finding that most drivers think they are a better-than-average driver. That one has always bugged me. How did this supposed poll def
by baddox 12y ago
> A popular example is the finding that most drivers think they are a better-than-average driver.
That one has always bugged me. How did this supposed poll define "average driver," if at all? Is the idea that you rank all drivers from best to worst, then see if you're in the top half of the list? Or is the idea to take some metric, like the average traffic tickets per driver, and see if you have more or fewer tickets than that average? If it's the former, I'm not sure how you distinguish between all the drivers with flawless driving records. If it's the latter, then I must be above average, since I've never had a traffic ticket.
The same questions apply to this poll, which asked people whether they are "more moral, kinder to others, more self-controlled, more law-abiding, more compassionate, more generous, more dependable, more trustworthy, and more honest" than average.
- bitJericho 12y agoIt's called a self assessment. Of all the drivers you've seen on the road, do you rate yourself above average compared to them? People are deluded all the time in their opinion of themselves. This result is really unsurprising to me.
- baddox 12y ago> Of all the drivers you've seen on the road, do you rate yourself above average compared to them? Using the second concept of "average," yes I do. I have seen lots of car accidents, and lots of people pulled over by police (presumably for speeding or reckless driving). I have never experienced either, other than being pulled over once for a missing tail light (humorously, literally hours after I had purchased that vehicle). So I do consider myself a better than average driver. But this idea of "better than average driver" just isn't very useful. Because presumably the majority of drivers have not been in an accident, while the average number of accidents per driver is obviously greater than zero. Thus most people are better than average drivers, in the same sense that most people have more fingers than average.
- bitJericho 12y agoWell you already fell for it. How could you possibly know if you're better than average without keeping track and comparing with other drivers in a scientific manner? For all you know, the bad drivers you see make up one tenth of one percent (made up figure), making the majority of below average drivers people who have never been pulled over or in an accident.
- baddox 12y ago> How could you possibly know if you're better than average without keeping track and comparing with other drivers in a scientific manner? Did you read the two definitions of "average" I posted above? Under the second definition, if we go by traffic accidents, I am clearly better than average, because I have been in zero traffic accidents (as a driver). Since you seem to be going by the first definition, I'm curious how you are distinguishing drivers that all have a perfect driving record.
- drewbug 12y agoHow do you know that most drivers have been in at least one traffic accident?
- jamestnz 12y agoIt's not necessary that most other drivers have had an accident for most people to have had below the average number of accidents. Consider a population of 100 drivers, none of whom have ever had a traffic accident. The average number of accidents per driver is therefore zero. Suddenly, two of them collide. Now, 2/100 drivers have had an accident, and 98/100 drivers have still never had an accident. The average number of accidents per driver is now therefore 0.02. Since 98/100 drivers have had 0 accidents, but the average number of accidents per driver is 0.02, then 98% of drivers have had below the average number of accidents.
- drewbug 12y ago
- seanflyon 12y agoI would define "better-than-average driver" by the expected value of deaths, injuries, and damage you will cause in the next year.
- bjourne 12y agoWe on hacker news knows the difference between mean and median. But there is no need to be anal retentive about it. If someone says they are better than average it means they think they are better than 50% of the population. Note also that mean and median are approximately equal for large populations given a normal distribution. Most metrics about humans follow a normal distribution with notable exceptions like salary. I don't know if driving skill follows a normal distribution or not, but if I had to bet I know what I would have bet on. :)