7 ms·
Jailed criminals think they are more kind, trustworthy and honest than average
- spindritf 12y agoI'm guessing that criminals move in a little different circles than most people and it's their perception of "an average member of the community" that may be skewed rather than perception of self.
- pessimizer 12y agoThat's a bit of a false dilemma.
- elpachuco 12y agoYou really need to explain what you mean because his explanation seems to make sense to me.
- pessimizer 12y ago>it's their perception of "an average member of the community" that may be skewed rather than perception of self. My problem is with the word "rather." It can be any degree of either in combination.
- mercer 12y agoYou could argue that the two are intwined: how much of a 'self' do we really have that is not strongly linked to 'our' community?
- Crito 12y agoThere doesn't have to be a problem with that explanation if you consider the possibility that what this study observed was not necessarily always the case. Perhaps generation 1 of criminals committed crimes out of perceived necessity, but did not believe themselves to be acting morally. They failed to stress this to their children however, perhaps due to some sense of pride, and the second generation is then raised to believe that crime is normal. This second generation, unlike the first, could have an inaccurate sense of what "normal" morality is.
- pessimizer 12y agoIt doesn't have to be either/or.
- chc 12y agoIt's extremely unlikely to be both in exactly equal portion, so insofar as we're looking for a primary cause, it probably is either/or.
- gscott 12y agoFor some reason I am currently addicted to this show that follows inmates around in prison and one thing every inmate eventually says "I'm locked up with a bunch of criminals!". Then the second thing they do is compare their crime to another and concludes they are not nearly as bad as the rapist or killer. Amazingly people who kill, rape, etc are all together with someone who stole a car, broke into a house, was caught with drugs.
- anigbrowl 12y agoWhich show is this, please? The ethics of crime are a complex subject, and while convicts' own views on the subject are generally self-serving there are shades of grey all over. For example, I knew a bar owner who murdered a heroin dealer, because one of the bar owner's friends OD'ed and died. So he waited until the heroin dealer went into the restroom at the bar one night, then followed him in and shot him dead. That's pretty cold-blooded (from a legal standpoint, advance planning like that is considered far worse than shooting someone in the heat of a dispute), but then it seems morally mild compared to murdering someone for personal gain. I can't find it now, but there was a really fascinating article posted here a year or so ago about an undercover cop whose specialty is pretending to be a hitman, and the people who attempt to hire his services. Maybe someone else will remember enough detail to turn it up in a search.
- gscott 12y agoIt is Locked Up available online too at http://www.msnbc.com/lockup http://www.msnbc.com/lockup. Basically the idea is to shove a lot of inmates into a small space and have them mill about aimlessly then see what happens.
- mercer 12y agoIn my experience both are true (and intrinsically linked): people I know who engage in various degrees of criminal activity both move in circles where this is acceptable, and in large part because of these circles they perceive themselves as not being criminals (but rather misunderstood, fighting the man, not buying into society's beliefs, etc.). Another good example of this dynamic can be seen with alcoholics (whichever stage of alcoholism they might be in). I read recently that apparently about 30% of the US population does not drink at all, and about 10% are outliers (10+ drinks per day!). http://kottke.org/14/10/the-united-states-of-alcoholism http://kottke.org/14/10/the-united-states-of-alcoholism. Having been a non-drinker for most of my life, and a heavy drinker for part of my life, in both cases I felt I was (mostly) 'average'. Of course, what I failed to take into account was that in my non-drinking period I was part of a community of non-drinkers, and I barely interacted with those who drink a lot, whereas in my drinking period I didn't interact with the 'boring lot' who don't drink and leave parties at such early times as 12 PM. Another example of this is sexuality. I spent a significant period of of my life practicing abstinence (conservative christian), and a more recent period in an environment where casual sex was the norm. I always thought that this more recent period was the actual 'normal', until I decided to look up 'actual' averages. I thought having a sexual partner count in the double-digits was pretty normal, but apparently here in Holland the average amount of partners is around 6, and the median is lower than that.
- baddox 12y ago> A popular example is the finding that most drivers think they are a better-than-average driver. That one has always bugged me. How did this supposed poll define "average driver," if at all? Is the idea that you rank all drivers from best to worst, then see if you're in the top half of the list? Or is the idea to take some metric, like the average traffic tickets per driver, and see if you have more or fewer tickets than that average? If it's the former, I'm not sure how you distinguish between all the drivers with flawless driving records. If it's the latter, then I must be above average, since I've never had a traffic ticket. The same questions apply to this poll, which asked people whether they are "more moral, kinder to others, more self-controlled, more law-abiding, more compassionate, more generous, more dependable, more trustworthy, and more honest" than average.
- bitJericho 12y agoIt's called a self assessment. Of all the drivers you've seen on the road, do you rate yourself above average compared to them? People are deluded all the time in their opinion of themselves. This result is really unsurprising to me.
- baddox 12y ago> Of all the drivers you've seen on the road, do you rate yourself above average compared to them? Using the second concept of "average," yes I do. I have seen lots of car accidents, and lots of people pulled over by police (presumably for speeding or reckless driving). I have never experienced either, other than being pulled over once for a missing tail light (humorously, literally hours after I had purchased that vehicle). So I do consider myself a better than average driver. But this idea of "better than average driver" just isn't very useful. Because presumably the majority of drivers have not been in an accident, while the average number of accidents per driver is obviously greater than zero. Thus most people are better than average drivers, in the same sense that most people have more fingers than average.
- bitJericho 12y agoWell you already fell for it. How could you possibly know if you're better than average without keeping track and comparing with other drivers in a scientific manner? For all you know, the bad drivers you see make up one tenth of one percent (made up figure), making the majority of below average drivers people who have never been pulled over or in an accident.
- smtddr 12y agoI'm sure the "shock value" in this headline is the assumption that most people have in their heads: criminals in jail = bad people. One factor to note in this, is that there are a lot of people in jail who arguably shouldn't be there. People who are, in fact, not much different from you or I. I suspect on average, the people in jail aren't that different from the people outside of it in terms of morals & ethics.... on average.
- pessimizer 12y ago>I'm sure the "shock value" in this headline is the assumption that most people have in their heads: criminals in jail = bad people. Not for me. For me, criminals in jail = on average worse than average unjailed people.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- baddox 12y agoThe average person in prison would be worse than the average person not in prison, at least if we assume a naive model whereby most violent criminals are caught and imprisoned for some extended period of time. But it could also be true that most people in prison are not worse than the average person not in prison. Of course, this is also assuming away the vague and subjective task of determining "how bad" a person is.
- pessimizer 12y agoWe don't have to assume anything. It's self-determined.
- baddox 12y agoI'm not talking about how people respond. I'm talking about whether we consider the responses to be accurate. Usually, the implication is that people are overestimating their own merit.
- S4M 12y agoWould it be possible that the criminals gave those answers hoping that this survey would actually be monitored, and its result be used for parole?
- baddox 12y agoAnd, even more generally, there seems to be little incentive in assessing yourself poorly in an anonymous poll.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- krick 12y agoI easily believe that often that can be the case.
- bambax 12y ago> A popular example is the finding that most drivers think they are a better-than-average driver. The explanation in the article (that most people really are good drivers and that the average is drawn "low" because of very bad drivers) is flat-out wrong. The correct explanation is described in detail in Daniel Kahneman' Thinking, Fast and Slow. It's impossible to assess our own position on the grand scale of driving ability; when the brain gets asked a difficult question, it quietly changes the question to a similar one, much easier to answer. So when people are asked "are you a better-than-average driver", since they have no idea what the average is (or what the average means) they answer instead the question "am I an okay driver" and answer "yes". This is probably what happens with prisoners too (or, they're actually kinder than the average people they know, and that's why they got caught).
- evincarofautumn 12y agoHow do we know this has anything to do with self-perception? Negative feelings tend to be given more weight—a bad review of a restaurant is much more likely to make you avoid it than a good review is to make you visit it—so people could simply believe that “the average person” is worse (at driving, being honest, &c.) than the true average. If I see several traffic accidents a year, I note that since I haven’t had one, I must be doing better than the nebulous category of “other drivers”. After all, the probability of someone else’s having an accident this year is scrillions of times higher than the probability of my having one, even if every individual driver is about as good as me.
- S_A_P 12y agoUpvote just for mentioning this book! I purchased, started reading and have subsequently forgotten to finish this book after work got in the way.
- bambax 12y agoOh read it, read it, it's fantastic.
- baddox 12y agoI can't speak to how everyone interprets the question, and I don't know if you have actual data on how people interpret the question (you mention that book, but I haven't read it). I can tell you that I consider myself to be a better than average driver because I have never been in an accident (as a driver) or received any traffic infractions, which is the interpretation you call "flat-out wrong." If I had been in an accident or received a traffic infraction, then I would have to actually consult data to determine whether I am above or below average. Until then, I think I have a very reasonable claim to being above average.
- rqebmm 12y agoI wouldn't be surprised if this is a result of a victim mentality. It's very possible they look around them and see themselves as the ones placed in dire situations because other people weren't kind, trustworthy, or honest with them, and that's why they had to resort to criminal activities. This kind of attitude is (often rightly) prevalent in people on the fringes of societies.
- imgabe 12y agoPeople generally don't consider themselves to be bad people. Even if they've done something bad, in their own mind there is bound to be a justification for it.
- squozzer 12y agoThe site itself had a very interesting comment - that the study assumed the convicts were worse than average. We don't know the exact nature of the crimes. Another question lies in whom the convicts were comparing themselves. If I were a burglar whose friends were all hit men or divorce lawyers, I might find some justification in feeling a little morally superior.
- dyeje 12y agoCmon guys, I literally learned this is Psychology 101. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illusory_superiority http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illusory_superiority