3 ms·
> What you do see though, in the same Fortune 400 list is that 6 of the top 10 people on that list didn't build their companies (in the sense that Bill Gates di
by humanrebar 12y ago
> What you do see though, in the same Fortune 400 list is that 6 of the top 10 people on that list didn't build their companies (in the sense that Bill Gates did), they inherited them.
But 10 out of the top ten did not have billionaires for grandparents. The Kochs and Waltons are second-generation billionaires. They're not the product of hundreds of years of steadily accumulating wealth. So there's a flaw in the thesis that wealth continues to grow. There's a significant amount of churn in the ranks of the superwealthy.
- ska 12y agoDoes churn from super-wealthy to "merely" wealthy address Piketty's thesis? For that matter, does it matter if the names change? Distribution of wealth skewing towards a small number of people is still inequality in the sense that Piketty is talking about, even if the names of the people change every 10 years, let alone every few generations. In other words I think what Piketty is getting at is if there is a decay term, it has to act fast enough that the wealth is distributed broadly before it is all collected up by some other small group of people, otherwise there is little functional difference to dynastic wealth.
- m0th87 12y agoPiketty addresses this specifically in pointing out that wealth had to be reconstructed almost from scratch following WW2. If you buy his thesis, then this wealth will be inherited by third- and fourth- generation billionaires next, unless another shock at the scale of WW2 happens.
- aidenn0 12y agoI buy into that thesis for Europe, but the continental US was largely shielded from the destruction of WW2.
- m0th87 12y agoTrue! For the US, concentration of wealth was lower than Europe pre-WW2, but is higher today. According to him, that's because the wealthy here only had to contend with the Depression, and avoided most of the shocks of WW2.
- krisdol 12y agoThe ratio of capital-to-labor money was at an unusual low even in the US during that era. It has since been returning to its pre-WW2 levels. Piketty addresses WW2 a lot in his book, for many reasons including that this economic anomaly occurred during this period.