3 ms·
To Explain Longevity Gap, Look Past Health System
- Mz 17y agoI belong to a number of health-related lists. The debate about the healthcare system raged on endlessly on some of those lists. Any time I said that there are other differences between the US and other countries besides who pays the medical bills, it was largely ignored. So I was happy to see this article -- and never mind that it is also getting ignored as there are no comments on it (other than mine now).
- jamesbritt 17y agoI had posted this partly because it offered another point of view on the health care debate, but mostly as an example of how people can misunderstand data and come to suspect conclusions. I would think this is of general interest to people looking to understand a market or some behavior. Certainly more comments would be welcome.
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoAs much as I like fact-based smackdowns, this seem a bit thin to me. Particularly the big conclusion: “The U.S. has had one spectacular achievement in preventive medicine,” he says. “It has had the largest drop in cigarette consumption per adult of any developed country since 1985.” But didn't we just learn, a few paragraphs back that: "For four decades, until the mid-1980s, per-capita cigarette consumption was higher in the United States (particularly among women) than anywhere else in the developed world." So the one big comparative success in preventative medicine may just be a statistical fluke based on the larger number of smokers. How do the stats compare if you ask what percentage of smokers quit? If the percentage is the exact same the US per-capita drop would be higher simply because more cigarettes were smoked intially. I'm also not sure being "more likely to recieve medication" for a short list of problems is necessarily a good thing if lifestyle changes could have a better effect (both from the perspective of the patient and of taxpayers funding the treatment).