3 ms·
I think some of Gates criticisms fall in the arm chair category of criticisms on this, honestly. (And to be fair, I know mine do.) I have no desire to silence
by taeric 12y ago
I think some of Gates criticisms fall in the arm chair category of criticisms on this, honestly. (And to be fair, I know mine do.) I have no desire to silence any of them, and I am excited about seeing them debated. But, I am fairly skeptical about how good they are.
I am genuinely interested in any discussions on this. Though, I will probably duck out of it soon, as it is beyond me. Please keep it going.
Regarding the investments, I am really talking about individual investors more than the companies. Find me someone with a couple hundred k in investments, and I posit you have found someone that will remain wealthy for some time. Probably long enough to pass it on to their children. Find me someone with a million in investments, and I am even more sure. More, they are in a position to make it so that most dollars they spend directly relate to some more dollars they will make.
I believe you are correct, historically. However, in recent times the wealthy are more and more made up from people that invested well. Pretty much period.
Consider your average home buyer. (Well, scratch that, consider your average successful home buyer.) The banks and lenders gain more from the purchase than the purchaser does. By a pretty large margin. If we look at the ones that go bust, this is even more true.
I agree that we don't need to tear down successful folk. I'm just not sure I've heard any plans that successfully help the less successful ones.
- bsbechtel 12y ago>I think some of Gates criticisms fall in the arm chair category of criticisms on this, honestly. (And to be fair, I know mine do.) I have no desire to silence any of them, and I am excited about seeing them debated. But, I am fairly skeptical about how good they are. Mine as well, and neither of us have time to compile the data that Piketty has done. Appreciate your thoughtful criticisms.
- taeric 12y agoEven if I had the time, not sure I have the skill. I suppose the idea would be I could build the skill with enough time. Regardless, is very fun to consider ideas on this. Thank you for the thread!