3 ms·
I'm not sure I understand your other option. If the government doesn't have control over the flow of wealth, why do you think it will not just increasingly flo
by taeric 12y ago
I'm not sure I understand your other option. If the government doesn't have control over the flow of wealth, why do you think it will not just increasingly flow to those in power?
I understand the concern over governments that are not acting in the best interest of the people. However, abstaining from the process seems a very shaky way to actually get it to act in an appropriate way.
More to the point, I thought the entire premise was that investment has been going up for the sake of investment lately. Which means the main people benefiting from the investment of the wealthy, are the wealthy that are investing.
This odd conflation of philanthropy with investment just smacks of rationalizing high earnings in an "I deserve it" blanket. Yes, more philanthropy is good. No, more investment isn't the same as more philanthropy.
And, no, we don't need to eliminate consumption any more than we need to eliminate investment. Or, rather, I don't know as that we do. (I'm not that bright, all told.) What I do think we need is to increase the benefit to everyone from investment and consumption (and philanthropy). Not just those that are controlling it.
- bsbechtel 12y ago>I'm not sure I understand your other option. If the government doesn't have control over the flow of wealth, why do you think it will not just increasingly flow to those in power? Up until roughly 1903, the US didn't have any personal income taxes. There was a small business tax, and this was it. Gates' own example of old money no longer existing didn't really point to examples such as the Waltons, but to families who have had wealth for hundreds of years due to large estates. He's correct that this wealth no longer exists. My argument would be that it no longer exists because in the 1800s, neither the wealthy nor the labor class were taxed as individuals, r and g roughly equalized and the wealthy didn't maintain their wealth. This phenomenon of extreme inequality started to occur only in the early 1900s, the same time the US first implemented a personal income tax (thus taxing labor more so than wealth, lowering g and raising r).
- taeric 12y agoSeems like a very small amount of evidence to base such a large idea on. You could probably form the same argument against the more modern consumption taxes. Since for many this translates to a sales tax, and not the early excise taxes that are covered under the same category. (Right?) Though, your argument falls more heavily on the mistake Gates seems to have also made. The type of wealth that the book refers to as "old wealth" really refers to a rentier based society. This is somewhat important, because much of what would have been the "old money" in the US was effectively disrupted by massive technology changes. It isn't that the old wealth just disappeared, it was not created in such a way that it sustained itself. This is important, because wealth in the modern US does sustain itself. Quite heavily, even.
- bsbechtel 12y ago>Seems like a very small amount of evidence to base such a large idea on. I acknowledge this. Keep in mind though that in economics it is extremely difficult to comprehensively analyze all the data relevant to your stated hypothesis. Gates points out several areas where Piketty's data falls short, and the amount of data Piketty collected and analyzed for his book is considered one of the strongest points of his thesis. >This is important, because wealth in the modern US does sustain itself. Quite heavily, even. Are you talking about Google, Apple, Walmart, etc, or financiers on Wall Street? Or could you expand in general on this? The companies I listed invest heavily in R&D (creating jobs and a better product for the consumer, and sustaining their wealth in the process). Aside from Warren Buffett, I'm under the impression most wealthy individuals in the financial services industry fail to maintain their wealth for the long term, although I don't have any specific examples on hand to support that point. Aside from this, if modern wealth sustains itself through natural processes, then great! We should be looking for ways to make other people just as wealthy, not figuring out ways to tear down those who have been successful.
- taeric 12y agoI think some of Gates criticisms fall in the arm chair category of criticisms on this, honestly. (And to be fair, I know mine do.) I have no desire to silence any of them, and I am excited about seeing them debated. But, I am fairly skeptical about how good they are. I am genuinely interested in any discussions on this. Though, I will probably duck out of it soon, as it is beyond me. Please keep it going. Regarding the investments, I am really talking about individual investors more than the companies. Find me someone with a couple hundred k in investments, and I posit you have found someone that will remain wealthy for some time. Probably long enough to pass it on to their children. Find me someone with a million in investments, and I am even more sure. More, they are in a position to make it so that most dollars they spend directly relate to some more dollars they will make. I believe you are correct, historically. However, in recent times the wealthy are more and more made up from people that invested well. Pretty much period. Consider your average home buyer. (Well, scratch that, consider your average successful home buyer.) The banks and lenders gain more from the purchase than the purchaser does. By a pretty large margin. If we look at the ones that go bust, this is even more true. I agree that we don't need to tear down successful folk. I'm just not sure I've heard any plans that successfully help the less successful ones.