6 ms·
Two rational people cannot end up at s different conclusion. If they do, one of them has faulty logic, or incorrect priors. People against drugs mostly tend to
by MichaelGG 12y ago
Two rational people cannot end up at s different conclusion. If they do, one of them has faulty logic, or incorrect priors.
People against drugs mostly tend to have wildly inaccurate priors. Sort of like creationists. If you have a terrible understanding of evolution ("monkeys randomly turned into people, fish randomly got legs and started walking just because ") then you'll end up at an invalid conclusion. Likewise, if you believe the very inaccurate drug info out there, your conclusions will be wrong.
Less often, someone has good beliefs on the actual drugs, but poor beliefs on personal freedom, or faulty logic on the drug war.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoDenying rationality to the opposition is pretty much the definition of an 'ad hominem' attack. There's a wonderful paper of the fundamental difference between the values of people who self-label as 'conservative' and those who self-label as 'liberal'. It has to do with how they prioritize values such as personal liberty, respect for institutions, adherence to authority etc. Both value them; but they prioritize them completely differently. So, that aristotlean view above may call everything black and white, but actual people start from different premises. So they reach different conclusions. Its good to respect other's culture including their premises on how we organize our society. Instead of just calling them idiots or that they have 'poor beliefs'. They just don't match yours. Its good because you can understand them, and have a hope of arguing effectively with them. Instead of disaffecting them by calling them names. Which feels good for a moment, but just balls up any chances of a dialog.
- colanderman 12y agoOr they have differing value systems? Or both have incomplete information? Or both conclusions are valid?
- MichaelGG 12y agoIncomplete info or different value systems are a case of incorrect priors. If "incorrect priors" bothers you for the difference between "People should always be productive" versus "People should do what they want" then feel free to say "different priors". The end result is the same.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoNothing to do with priors. Has to do with weights and priorities. Or is that what you mean by 'priors'?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- pc2g4d 12y ago"Two rational people cannot end up at [a] different conclusion" Wow. I couldn't disagree more. There's so much ambiguity in this world of ours that, even given a universally agreed upon definition of "rational" (which usually is a stand-in for "people whose thinking I approve of") there is enormous room for differing conclusions. The belief that "rational" people must come to same conclusions seems like a basis for transferring the argument from the issues to the people. I.e. if you're "rational" and not coming to the same conclusions as I am then there must be something wrong with you.
- MichaelGG 12y ago"More specifically, if two people are genuine Bayesian rationalists with common priors, and if they each have common knowledge of their individual posteriors, then their posteriors must be equal." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aumann%27s_agreement_theorem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aumann%27s_agreement_theorem But yes, essentially, even colloquially, if we're both rational and coming to different conclusions, then either one of is making a mistake, or one of has a incorrect assumption. In the case of there being no correct assumption ("red is better color than green"), then feel free to call it "different" assumptions.
- pc2g4d 12y agoIn that case "rationality" basically means following the laws of probability theory given an existing statistical model. However, the process of arriving at the statistical model to begin with is fraught with areas of potential disagreement. The promises of that agreement theorem are actually pretty narrow and essentially reduce down to "math is consistent with itself".
- MichaelGG 12y agoYou're not wrong. But it should be explicitly noted and let people reduce their arguments to "my priors say an invisible force has a terminal value of consuming drugs being bad". Then instead of saying how people disagree, we can just note that people have flawed beliefs. Otherwise talking about agreement somehow seems like there's a problem with the correct side, that hey "both are valid" and so on.