3 ms·
> Cost of a false positive here would have been a nurse who was inconvenienced. Cost of a false negative is at a minimum the time and expense of contact-trackin
by baddox 12y ago
> Cost of a false positive here would have been a nurse who was inconvenienced. Cost of a false negative is at a minimum the time and expense of contact-tracking 132 people who flew with her, the cost to the airline of taking the plane out of service (which they've already done), and a severe drop of public confidence in the CDC.
Perhaps the cost of allowing a lot of personal discretion from the CDC workers who make these decisions would be even higher than either.
- hga 12y agoLittle "discretion" applied here, from reports. The drone at the CDC looked it up, 100.4 F is the official threshold, and gave her the all clear without taking a step back and saying, hey, let's be extra cautious for her class of close contact (can't quite say "exposed" at that time).
- baddox 12y agoWhat's the distribution of human body temperatures? I don't know, but it's at least plausible that invoking the restrictive policies for body temperatures below the official threshold would, in the long term, be more costly than strictly enforcing the official threshold.