7 ms·
This makes me sad on so many levels. One, because it's sad that the US government has so much ability to force other sovereign entities to bend to its will, an
by mindcrime 12y ago
This makes me sad on so many levels. One, because it's sad that the US government has so much ability to force other sovereign entities to bend to its will, and two, because paying more taxes to the US government is never a good thing. I personally support anybody who finds new and creative ways to avoid sending tax dollars to the USG... after all, not everybody wants to fund the US's empire building overseas wars, torture camps, surveillance infrastructure, propaganda machine, and massive money-wasting bureaucracy.
> As we've always said, it's for governments to decide the law and for companies to comply with it
That is so fatalistic and depressing. Everybody should feel empowered to work to shape what "the law" is. Personally, I want society's notion of "the law" rolled back to just how Bastiat[1] defined it:
"What, then, is law? It is the collective organization of the individual right to lawful defense. "
I'm also reminded of what Bastiat said about lawful plunder and the perversion of the law:
But, generally, the law is made by one man or one class of men. And since law cannot operate without the sanction and support of a dominating force, this force must be entrusted to those who make the laws.
This fact, combined with the fatal tendency that exists in the heart of man to satisfy his wants with the least possible effort, explains the almost universal perversion of the law. Thus it is easy to understand how law, instead of checking injustice, becomes the invincible weapon of injustice. It is easy to understand why the law is used by the legislator to destroy in varying degrees among the rest of the people, their personal independence by slavery, their liberty by oppression, and their property by plunder. This is done for the benefit of the person who makes the law, and in proportion to the power that he holds.
[1]: http://bastiat.org/en/the_law.html http://bastiat.org/en/the_law.html
- bogomipz 12y agoDo you realize that Google, Facebook, Oracle et al. are US companies? These companies all benefited from the stable business climate that the US government largely provides(stable judicial system, Delaware Companies, a stable financial system, State University systems that provide research grants that made Google possible in first place etc.) So why should these Corporations that benefitted from that not pay their fare share of taxes? I hate pay taxes too but I pay them and I understand that they pay for services I benefit from. You sound both naive and uninformed. Its a farce that American companies that make billions pay almost no tax on those profits while us little people shoulder the burden. Did you actually read the article?
- briandh 12y agoThe "fair share" rhetoric so frequently deployed in these contexts would be more convincing if US corporate tax policy was more in line with international norms and if less tax revenue funded policies ranging from wasteful to downright immoral.
- Retric 12y ago'Normalizing' taxes with the rest of the world would be a massive taxes increase on huge numbers of companies. We might have a high nominal rate, but companies can often get vary low effective tax rates. Arguably, what we need is a corporate AMT and a lower top tax bracket. Otherwise some companies focus on paying zero taxes where others simply focus on being profitable.
- briandh 12y agoIt's not just the nominal rate. The average effective corporate tax rate is also quite a bit higher for the US than other developed countries; according to a report by PricewaterhouseCoopers and the World Bank, 27.9% versus an OECD average of 15.9%. [1 citing 2] The right wing think-tank AEI reported a smaller disparity of about 9% a few years earlier. [3] For what it's worth, these rates are fairly variable over the years. So "huge numbers" seems like quite a stretch. Moreover, I used the broader term "policies" rather than "rates" for a reason. The US's worldwide taxation scheme, for instance, is in itself problematic. [1] http://barbwire.com/2014/10/15/analysis-are-us-corporate-taxes-really-the-highest-in-the-world/ http://barbwire.com/2014/10/15/analysis-are-us-corporate-tax... [2] http://www.doingbusiness.org/~/media/GIAWB/Doing%20Business/Documents/Special-Reports/Paying-Taxes-2014.pdf http://www.doingbusiness.org/~/media/GIAWB/Doing%20Business/... [3] http://www.aei.org/article/economics/fiscal-policy/taxes/report-card-on-effective-corporate-tax-rates/ http://www.aei.org/article/economics/fiscal-policy/taxes/rep...
- Retric 12y agoAfter examining 288 corporations that where consistently profitable every year for 5 years. On average they "paid an effective federal income tax rate of just 19.4 percent." Which is close to the "15.9 percent" you linked. However, "Twenty-six of the corporations, including Boeing, General Electric, Priceline.com and Verizon, paid no federal income tax at all over the five year period. A third of the corporations (93) paid an effective tax rate of less than ten percent over that period." The point is with such high variability in tax rate's companies spend a lot of time looking for ways to avoid paying taxes vs. building better products etc. PS: Yea, just like the articles you linked this is also biased but the numbers are not made up. http://www.ctj.org/corporatetaxdodgers/sorrystateofcorptaxes.pdf http://www.ctj.org/corporatetaxdodgers/sorrystateofcorptaxes...
- deciplex 12y ago>it's sad that the US government has so much ability to force other sovereign entities to bend to its will We're all sovereign entities, and we all bend. I don't see why the Republic of Ireland should be any different. That said, wasn't this more due to pressure from the EU, than the US?
- mindcrime 12y agoIt isn't about the Republic of Ireland, it's about the US government and its excessive level of influence. My feelings would be the same if the other party had been Russia, Malaysia, Turkmenistan or Canada. It's not like this is the first time the US has thrown its weight around in a way that's detrimental to individual freedom. Look, for example, at how they made the Swiss cave in on reporting financial transactions in a way that the Swiss historically never did.
- anigbrowl 12y agoI'm Irish (although I live in the US now) and I thought this scheme was a hideous national embarrassment. I don't care for my home country to be associated with accounting shenanigans. If corporations who find the US tax regime unfair spent as much energy on lobbying for an alternative as they do in playing financial find-the-lady then we might enjoy a simpler and fairer tax code in the US. Also, I think your arguments about it being some sort of moral alternative to supporting the evil US government with tax dollars is patent nonsense. Ireland's motivations in offering this tax structure were purely mercenary; handing out subsidies in the form overly-generous tax treatment is an old-fashioned tactic that Irish governments have used many times in the past to attract foreign employers. On past form quite a few of those jobs will evaporate along with the expiration of the favorable tax treatment.
- mindcrime 12y agoIreland's motivations are irrelevant. I'm not taking issue with anything Ireland did, or didn't do. Again, this has nothing to do with Ireland per-se. What makes me sad is the way the US can seemingly dominate pretty much anybody (excepting maybe Russia and China, and I'm not even sure about that) and force other countries into following our policies. Just to reiterate... I'd be sad about this if the other party involved had been any other country... Trans-Dniester, Sealand, Syria, Zimbabwe, whoever.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- clavalle 12y agoThe depth of Anarcho-Capitalist or strong Libertarian pessimism astounds me. > because paying more taxes to the US government is never a good thing. > not everybody wants to fund the US's empire building overseas wars, torture camps, surveillance infrastructure, propaganda machine, and massive money-wasting bureaucracy. Do you really think this is what the bulk of our taxes in the US go to? What about taking care of our sick? Funding projects that are too risky for our current quarter to quarter ROI business culture? Keeping people from starving? Taking care of the disabled? Education? I could go on and on. Even our 'Imperial military' does a lot of humanitarian good across the world and responds to disasters like no other organization on Earth. I'm not saying it is all sunshine and lollipops. Obviously there are things that I'd rather our government not do, but, when it comes to living in a Democratic Republic, sometimes you have to accept the will of the majority even if you don't agree with it. And sometimes there is enough room for bad actors to do things that range from unethical to appalling. It is a process of constant reform. It always will be. But calling for a dismantling, to toss away the collected, hard earned, wisdom of the last 250 years codified into laws and hundreds of years of Common Law before that because parts are lousy? Honestly, that just seems like a lazy approach. Not to mention an approach that lacks imagination when it comes to really mentally modelling what such a system would look like without resorting to near utopian wishful thinking. I mean, really, laws, like sysadmins, are doing their job well when you hardly notice they are there. The stuff you are noticing is horrible, but it is just the surface oil slick on a much calmer and more important sea.
- mindcrime 12y agoThe depth of Anarcho-Capitalist or strong Libertarian pessimism astounds me. I'm not sure how you concluded that the Anarcho-Capitalist position is a pessimistic one. I'd say it's exactly the opposite! We are the ones who are optimistic enough to believe that we don't need a huge government apparatus, collecting tax dollars at the end of a gun barrel, and using that money to fund aggressive use of force, in order to have a peaceful, just, and fair society. From where I'm sitting, it looks like it's the bastardised modern-day "liberalism" that is so full of pessimism. These people think that we need widespread use of coercive force in order to have peace and justice. It's exactly what Bastiat was saying when he spoke about the law becoming a perversion of itself. Obviously there are things that I'd rather our government not do, but, when it comes to living in a Democratic Republic, sometimes you have to accept the will of the majority even if you don't agree with it. Well yeah, if you're outnumbered and outgunned and the majority show a propensity for violence. I'm reminded of the old saw: "Democracy is two wolves and a sheep voting on what to have for lunch. Liberty is a well-armed sheep contesting the vote".
- negamax 12y agoMany other countries have lower defense spending because of high US defense spending.
- troels 12y agoThat's a hard to verify claim. Although the opposite is most certainly true - That a many other countries have a higher defence spending because of high US defence spending.