3 ms·
On the possible consciousness of rocks and panpsychism (title by Kottke)
- Tichy 19y agoThe reason that consciousness eludes science is simple: nobody has ever given a proper definition of it. All talk about consciousness is therefore only hot air.
- euccastro 19y agoIs that a reason or a symptom?
- jkkramer 19y agoI would submit that to properly define something, you have to understand it. Since consciousness is not understood, it has no definition. Talk about consciousness isn't hot air; it's an effort to understand. Science tends to be inductive: we have to leap from particular experiences to abstract principles. With consciousness, we have the experiences but haven't made the leap yet to principles.
- Tichy 19y agoI doubt that "with consciousness, we have experiences". I think consciousness is only an illusion. OK, try to name at least something you consider an aspect of consciousness? I already don't have a clue again what we are even talking about. What is "consciousness" supposed to mean?
- jkkramer 19y agoConsciousness is not an experience of something. It's the experience itself. So it doesn't have qualities--it IS qualities. It's not red, it's what it's like to see red. It's the immediate (no intermediary) subjective happenings of your conscious mind. I can't point you to it because my pointing is a view presented to you in consciousness. It's not mystical or anything. In fact, it requires less faith than anything else -- it's all you've ever known directly. You could be living in the real world or in the Matrix, it doesn't matter. Either way, consciousness doesn't change, just the contents of consciousness.
- Tichy 19y ago"It's the immediate (no intermediary) subjective happenings of your conscious mind." Circular definition, doesn't work. So it is neurons firing, fine. I just don't know why we need entire research departments and conferences for that. Or do you mean it is creating a model of the perceived world? Computers can do that without a problem (quality of the model is a different matter). Does it puzzle people in the same way how computer chips can process information? Why not? (I am not talking about algorithms or electronics - those are interesting)
- coffeeaddicted 19y agoThe best text I've read so far on that topic is the one from chalmers: http://www.imprint.co.uk/chalmers.html http://www.imprint.co.uk/chalmers.html He made a strong argumentation for the difference between experiencing something and having a experiencing state. After that he also gets somewhat speculative, but at least reading the first 2 points is worth it.
- shawndrost 19y ago"But the rock doesn't exert itself as a result of all this "thinking."" What, and we do? "How could the ineffable experience of tasting a strawberry ever arise from the equations of physics?" Physics, as applied here, is not subject to intuition. Confused arguments for and against, but I find myself considering the idea more than I had before.
- mynameishere 19y agoPanpsychism may be easier to parody than to refute. Much like Santa. The possibility of mind-bits floating around does not explain why the nervous system (which, at its earliest, has a well-understood and insensate habit of food-gathering) would have more than its fair share of mind-bits. We do understand how silicon, germanium, copper, etc, turn into a machine having something similar to thought processes, and these processes are 100 percent detached from the originating materials.
- euccastro 19y agoHow could the processes be detached from the materials, if their 'unfolding' is determined[1] by their physical properties? And how would those processes manifest without materials? Can there be consciousness without physical manifestation? [1] I'm ignoring open questions about determinism in physics since computers as we know them don't depend on that stuff.