3 ms·
It's the kind of "right" that only exists if other people provide it - people who quite reasonably, don't see your "right" as a reason they should work for free
by gaius 12y ago
It's the kind of "right" that only exists if other people provide it - people who quite reasonably, don't see your "right" as a reason they should work for free.
- cbd1984 12y agoThis is also true of a right to own land, unless you are actually out there physically patrolling your property with an intent to stop someone from trespassing. And after you stop that person, who's to say you had the right to, and that the person's friends shouldn't come back and teach you the error of your ways? My point is, if you can't have water because someone else claims they own it, their ownership claim is backed up by the positive effort of others just as much as your claim to the water is, if not more so. "Stable ownership is the gift of social law, and is given late in the progress of society." — Thomas Jefferson ( http://press-pubs.uchicago.edu/founders/documents/a1_8_8s12.html http://press-pubs.uchicago.edu/founders/documents/a1_8_8s12.... )
- anon1385 12y ago>unless you are actually out there physically patrolling your property with an intent to stop someone from trespassing. It's worth noting that in some countries (Scotland, Norway) there is no such thing as trespass. So not only do you not have government assistance with preventing people walking on your land, you are not legally allowed to enforce that yourself either. On the topic of land ownership: A Scottish miner is walking home one evening with a brace of pheasants. He unexpectedly meets the landowner who informs him that this is his land and he better hand over the pheasants: 'Your land eh' asks the miner. 'Yes', replies the laird, 'and my pheasants.' 'And who did you get this land from?' 'Well, I inherited it from my father.' 'And who did he get it from?' the miner insists. 'His father of course. The land has been in my family for over 400 years' the laird splutters. 'OK, so how did your family come to own this land 400 years ago?' the miner asks. 'Well… well… they fought for it!' 'Fine,' replies the miner. 'Take your jacket off and I'll fight you for it now.'
- arnsholt 12y agoAt least in Norway, it's not quite that there's no notion of trespass. But it only applies to (from memory) within 100 metres of cultivated land and houses and such. So you can trespass, just not in the forests and mountains. The freedom to roam doesn't include the right to hunt wherever you want though. =)
- arethuza 12y agoI don't think it's quite true to say there are no trespass laws in Scotland - there is still laws against aggravated and collective trespass and there is a rather long list of laws governing access to other peoples land. However, the general rule is that we do have a "right to roam" with the condition that people accessing land are sensible about it: http://www.outdooraccess-scotland.com/ http://www.outdooraccess-scotland.com/ Land ownership in Scotland is incredibly complex - I can recommend the book "The Poor Had No Lawyers: Who Owns Scotland and How They Got it": http://www.amazon.co.uk/The-Poor-Had-No-Lawyers/dp/178027114X http://www.amazon.co.uk/The-Poor-Had-No-Lawyers/dp/178027114...
- gambiting 12y agoHmmmm that's why we have democratic governments, and in some countries we have decided that since it's a right to have access to water, the government should handle distribution of water from our taxes. So people working at the facilities are still getting paid, but the water is provided for free* for any citizen. *yes, paid from the taxes, I feel like I need to point this out otherwise someone else will.
- JoachimS 12y agoNo. It is a formal right that the United States among other countries has signed and thus mus adhere to: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_Declaration_of_Human_Rights http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_Declaration_of_Human_...
- ArkyBeagle 12y agoWater as in a public water works is quite the public good. Given that water and sewage are closely related ( you can have sewage management without it, but it's riskier - we're talking outhouses, which require some management ), I'd be perfectly willing to help pay for poor people's water out of purest self interest. There's the problem of identifying who might be eligible, but I'm ignoring that for now.